A Novel Romance (TV Movie 2015) Poster

(2015 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
27 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Literary love
TheLittleSongbird27 September 2022
Throughout my recently started Hallmark film completest quest expanding (so The Spring Fever, Summer Nights, Fall Harvest etc blocks on top of the Christmas films) an interesting quest but very mixed one, there was never the mentality of expecting a classic or the film in question to be flawless. Which never was the case. There was always the expectation of seeing a film where one can see at least some effort rather than merely cash-in level.

Effort that can absolutely be seen in 'A Novel Romace'. It is only the second 2015 Hallmark film and already that year has gotten off to a promising start for Hallmark. No Hallmark film seen yet has been great, though many has had many great things while having a few not so good ones. Which is the case with 'A Novel Romance'. Really liked the concept, which was cute if familiar, and the film does a nice job with it while never doing anything extraordinary.

'A Novel Romance' isn't perfect. It is let down by the very rushed and very silly final act, with almost everything happening too hastily and most of it not ringing true. Like most Hallmark films, the ending is a bit too neat.

Was expecting to be pretty predictable, and was not disappointed in this respect, very by the letter.

However, so much is great. It is a very nice looking film, one of Hallmark's best looking 2015 films in my view. The scenery really does entrance and the photography doesn't cheapen it at all. The music at least fits tonally and in placement and has presence without being over-loud. The dialogue is sharp enough and flows naturally, while also having the right amount of sentiment (not too much in quality and quantity).

Characters aren't complex, then again that shouldn't be expected watching Hallmark, but aren't too stereotypical and are generally likeable enough. The story may be predictable and not perfect in execution, but it is incredibly charming, sweet without being too sugary and very heart-warming. There is a nice lightness to it too on the whole. The cast are all solid, with Amy Acker being especially engaging. Very nice chemistry with her and equally charming Dylan Bruce.

Summing up, nice film. 7/10.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Needed a Better Resolution
athompsonblue8 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The actors are good. But I would rework the script.

He should have just told her early on why his parentage led him to seek anonymity, and then that he became a writer with a pseudonym, and then that his pseudonym is Gabriel August.

She kind of overreacts to the reveal. So, he's a writer with a famous pseudonym. Big deal. The way she takes it, you would think he had stolen all the money in her bank account. He wasn't hiding some dirty secret. He was just waiting for the right time to confide a big, private thing about himself. As a critic, doesn't she know the plot to the Barber of Seville?

Then, after six months go by, she seeks him out like they can just pick up where they left off?
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An Enjoy Romance Drama
tabuno14 August 2021
Amy Acker gets another opportunity to present herself with her consistently busy career in television and movies. She stars in this typical romance drama as an aspiring writer reviewing books for a local newspaper. This predictable romance movie involves her character falling for the dashing, famous but anonymous writer that forms the basis of this movie like similar ones with the same plot outline. Both Amy and her co-star Dylan Bruce handle their performances competently with a smoothly written and edited script. Somehow this fun movie performs as expected even as it avoids becoming loaded down with redundant or repeatedly dull or boring scenes the audience has seen hundreds of times before. While not a breakout romance drama, the actors, director, and writers are able to carry this movie off as a worthwhile effort to be seen on Hallmark Movies Now.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Really Enjoyable
littlelo9425 April 2015
This movie really surprised me. When I read the premise I was quite skeptical, believing that this movie would be another one of Hallmark's cheesy rom-coms (not that that's a bad thing!) but I quality of this movie was great!

The lead actors were fantastic, particularly Amy Acker who delivered a great performance.

I thought the writing of this movie was really great, as it didn't end in the cliché way I thought it would. I liked that the characters faced more strife and trouble in their relationship than the average Hallmark romance.

9/10 stars. You lost the last star in the finale moment. Just a teensy bit corny. Otherwise a great flick. Recommended.
20 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An Enjoyable Romance
atlasmb12 September 2021
A novelist and a literary critic meet on a plane flight to Portland, but they don't exchange phone numbers or last names. The writer, Liam (Dylan Bruce), was interested, so when he accidentally discovers her identity later, he tracks her down at her newspaper job.

Sophie (Amy Acker) is dealing with a recent very-public breakup from her ex, who was in the public eye, and she has trust issues. Dylan writes under a pen name and has been resisting the publisher's wish that he reveal his identity. As their relationship blossoms, they deal with their issues separately and privately. Eventually, each must reveal their concerns (with trust and real identity) if they are to truly build a meaningful relationship.

The chemistry in this Hallmark romance is enough to make the story work.

Look for Charles Dutton as one of Sophie's friends who helps her evaluate the new man in her life. And Camille Mitchell as Liam's agent, who adds a spark to the story.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
These two are so adorable it is almost too sweet.
cgvsluis2 March 2022
I have never seen a more suited pair than these two. They are perfect for one another.

Amy Acker plays Sophie, an Oregon newspaper reporter who meets on a plane from New York to Portland, Liam Bradley the mysterious author of her favorite romance...only she doesn't know it. When he sees she has an advanced copy of his latest novel he solicits her honest opinion...unfortunately, it isn't good.

Hurt in the past by her celebrity ex-boyfriend in a very public way, Sophie is afraid of lies and dishonest men...Liam is afraid to tell Sophie who he really is. Will these two get together? Or will Liam's reveal drive Sophie away?

This is over the top with sweetness and these two couldn't be more adorable together...if that floats your boat, this could be the romantic Hallmark movie for you.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Meh
dallasallis19 January 2022
I rated as high as I did because I love Amy Acker & Dylan Bruce, but this story was so lame in parts that I could hardly get through it. The overreaction & manufactured melodrama had my eyes rolling HARD. I've enjoyed many Hallmark movies, but not this one.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Probably my favorite Hallmark movie
FrankWButterfield18 May 2020
This is a real story with heart and very little pretense. Both MC actors had very obvious chemistry. I highly recommend this to anyone with an interest in a deeper kind of romance. For a TV movie, it's there in many different ways. I see that it's for sale (as of this writing). For the first time ever, I'm going to buy a Hallmark movie since I want to be able to watch it again. And again... Thanks to everyone involved in this movie for what you created. You should all be proud.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Unlikable main character
jbstad25 February 2022
Poorly researched (publishing business) and a female character who lies and then dumps male lead bcz he didn't tell her he was a reclusive author. Wimpy character who is hard to like. Poor writing with weak conflict that must be manipulated.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very Romantic
bobclemons-1399913 March 2020
An enjoyable and heartfelt movie with excellent acting and good script.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Sorry, terrible movie
manfredpeter-0962819 May 2020
Way too melodramatic. Characters wimpy. Put me in bad mood. Except for the agent, supporting characters really stupid.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Wasted Opportunity
safelton_1122 September 2018
There are many things about this movie that were good/very good: very good actors, good cinematography, good conflict, good choice of Portland, OR, and New York city locations (actually the movie may have been filmed elsewhere), and very good chemistry between the 2 lead actors. The only problem is the script, and it's a big problem. It's almost as if the screenwriter tried as hard as possible to write the most trite and cliché'd script possible. There's not one clever thing in this movie, not one surprise, nothing that would distinguish it from many, many similar romantic movies; well, except some of those movies at least try to put in a surprise, some unexpected twist, which then might lead to other interesting things, etc. Just a few changes to the plot, maybe some clever turn(s) or something humorous, could have made this movie far more successful.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of my Hallmark favorites
jwayne_2419 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
First off, I have to say that this is one of my favorite Hallmark Channel movies ever, in my top 5. Amy Acker was very vulnerable in her character, but not unbelievable.

Amy plays a young woman who meets a man on a flight and they become attracted to each other. She does not know that he is a bestselling author, while he has to listen to her unknowingly criticize his latest novel. She has been burned by public humiliation in a bad relationship before and his parents died at an early age, so they both are wary of trust and she vows never to date a famous person again.

They date and fall in love, and in particular her three friends help her see that she shouldn't judge him based on someone else. Of course, she finds out who he really is in a very public way and she ends things. Even when he apologizes and it is clear she loves him, she refuses to be in the public eye.

But in true Hallmark fashion, with a little help from her friends and his agent, they reunite and have their happy ending. This was a true pleasure to watch and a very believable portrayal of what a real relationship could be like. No doubt, it is well worth watching.
19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
83 Minutes That I'll Never Get Back
maya-quinn16 July 2015
Warning: Spoilers
"A Novel Romance" was not only cliché, but actually painful.

I watched this movie on my laptop and I honestly had to pause it so I could breathe and move on. Not in the "oh this is so sweet I'm blushing and forgetting how to breathe" way but the "let me close my eyes for a moment as I consider how a two year old could have better written, directed and starred in this movie" way, a "let me focus on breathing so I don't throw up from all this cheese" way.

The entire thing was cheesy and predictable. Every moment was hard to watch and while I'd like to think myself an appreciator of cliché romcoms, this was something else. By now I've watched enough films to know that you shouldn't be constantly reminded that people are acting, there should be a level of suspension of disbelief. For goodness sake, some Disney Channel Original TV movies are better than this.

I think that the concept of the film was okay, but that it was the execution in every sense, that ultimately let "A Novel Romance" down.

A good script, performance and cinematography should make you feel something, move you, and the only thing that this film made me feel, was queasy.

1/10
17 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
No two weeks notice?
cawolfe-522257 January 2021
This movie contains a pet peeve of mine. In real life you don't just walk up to your boss and say "today is my last day and I am starting my own business in direct competition to yours" And, then the boss smiles and wishes her well? Seriously? Otherwise this is not a bad movie for its type, even with the cheesy ending.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Predictable Ho Hum movie
heidibetrug14 January 2017
This is a silly formulaic rom-com. Amy Acker plays Sophie the same way she plays every role; hesitant speech, fixed, semi-smile regardless of the line she's delivering and heavenward gaze with her eyes, rolled around at every opportunity as if someone told her she has expressive eyes, so she works them at every opportunity. The plot is thin: book critic unknowingly falls in love with the author of a book she's slammed. Sophie is supposed to be a writer and literary critic, in line for a New York magazine job, yet acts like an unsophisticated bumpkin, agog being seated in First Class, taking a selfie while riding in a limo "because her friends will never believe it!" Oh please. Liam is supposedly a very successful author of best-sellers but he's wowed by this small town, cardigan wearing woman who stalks him when he meets with a client and talks with "other women." I give it 3 stars only because the other cast members are OK (even if there IS a token, wise black man friend!) and the scenery is lovely. Shot in wonderfully scenic British Columbia, I'm always puzzled why the writers just don't set the films there; why must BC always "fill in " for US locations? Are we so parochial that we won't watch a movie set outside the US? Sheeesh.
17 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Truly Awful
brown_steve5 February 2015
A neat idea betrayed by a script that manipulates the characters like puppets. These Hallmark romances have a predictable arc, but there's usually a certain measure of believability in the complications that block culmination of the romance and in the emotional and intellectual competence of the contending not-yet-betrothed-partners.

The leading woman-puppet, despite being a book, film and theatre critic is given the emotional maturity of a middle school girl, and the the pseudonymous runaway-best-selling romance novelist child of movie star parents leading man-puppet is awarded the emotional competence of a high schooler with the most crippling case of communicative lockjaw I've ever seen.

Only the night before I'd seen another Hallmark movie, sweet and maybe a little sappy, but still lovely, "Away and Back."
14 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Really well done!
c-9749811 August 2019
Given all the elements of this story. I thought the acting was great the story well acted.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Good romantic comedy
surangaf5 August 2015
I only gave it 5/10, judging it as a general movie. But as a romantic comedy it scores much higher.

It ticks off all the usual romantic comedy plot points, very competently and satisfyingly. Man meets woman, falls in love, unwilling concealments leads to misunderstandings and obstacles, everything gets worked out at end with help of friends and love, there are tears. Though thankfully there is no villain.

It has likable (but not perfect) clean cut white characters, with token minority characters. It is shot in tourist brochure backgrounds.

It stays within the bounds of modern western politically correct 'liberal' ideology, as such is outside bounds of realism. It preaches honesty, being true to yourself, reality and power of perfect love, etc. As such most of the dialogue is not worth any attention.

However, i found movie genuinely funny at points, not unintentionally either.

Another extra, it has Amy Acker, always a very good thing in any movie or TV. Other actors were not bad performers either, though some of the direction was bit clumsy.
10 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Awesome
jewelch19 August 2021
This was a really very good movie. James Welch Henderson Arkansas 8/18/2021.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
More & more crappy movies...
MomomoZi29 May 2016
I have a question: which year is now? Is it 1950? 1800 or 2016? It's not a start of a cinema. But in this movie actors simply don't know how to act. Good idea was turned down by terrible acting. Dylan Bruce looks scared all the time, afraid of something or somebody. I'm not convinced with such low acting. Charles S. Dutton also acts like in school drama - shy and scared. What's going on? Overall - boring, way too boring. The movie could be splendid but actors playing is weak. While watching the only thought was in mind: fake fake fake. Such movies you forget after less than an hour... I don't recommend to waist time. Giving 2 stars only for the theme - books.
8 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A Disaster of a Denouement.
dr_wolfi_d30 July 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I found the intrinsic denouement, i.e. Liam's/Gabriel August's revealing his true identity, came WAY TOO LATE, and when it came, it turned into utter disappointment. Gabriel August had several opportunities and may I say weakly and meekly eschewed each of them -- and when he finally did reveal himself, it turned into a disaster. The viewer had been looking forward to the resolution for quite some time, and when it finally did occur, it was not a joyous moment of surprise but a painful-to-watch disintegration, a falling apart of the plot. I imagine the screenwriter, a Hanz Wasserburger, struggled to write a script that could hold suspense for 1 hr 26 min. The movie held my suspense for quite a while, but one can only be patient that long, AND THEN one is rewarded with disappointment.
6 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
***
edwagreen14 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is typical Hallmark fanfare where a guy who lost his famous parents in a plane crash turns to writing novels. He meets a girl who just broke up with someone famous and since no one knows that he is the famous writer, he doesn't say anything to her about his identity.

The picture becomes devoted to his inability to tell her or something occurring as he is about to. With the typical Hallmark trait, she leaves him after she finally finds out, but what is true with all Hallmark films, love conquers all.

Our heroine Amy Acker is appealing but she suffers from almost a childish voice which may become annoying as the film goes on. Charles S. Dutton, the philosophic like owner of the restaurant, plays a widower in the movie and relates everything to his dead wife.

Anyone notice that the guy who owned the book company is a almost-look alike for our president and the girl wanting an autograph closely resembles Chelsea Clinton.
11 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
"You are The Lie Detector!"
poj-man13 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
There is a great Reverend Horton Heat song titled "Lie Detector." Undoubtedly the characters in this movie never come close to either listening to music such as this or thinking that the exist in the song lyrics posted next:

"Waiting for a slip Ain't no way to live I gotta take the test If you've gotta give

You are the lie detector You are the lie detector You are the truth protector You are the lie detector girl, yeah

What kind of thing could be Running through your mind? What the hell you thinking that You're gonna find?

Officer, prosecutor Judge, and Jury too What the hell you think Exactly that you're gonna prove?" =========================== A Novel Romance is the story of a female acting like The Lie Detector. The loverboy who is supposedly a mega-million selling author who is famous...but she doesn't know what his face is like. Right.

This is a painfully awful movie of one-note characters doing cloying clever and stupid Lie Detector things; she even admits that she put him through "tests." His personality is so bland he just says "oh, OK." Any human I know would be enraged at being treated in such a manner that they would have the potential if not follow through of violence. Who wants to shack up with a hag who thinks it is so clever to put their lover through Lie Detector Tests?
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Must see . . .
crobertson28721 January 2015
A Novel Romance with Amy Acker is a must see. All of us have been in relationships even marriages where some of what is revealed in this movie must be dealt with. I'd never heard of Amy before but if you're a fan you will love her in this film. All acting is superb but Amy's performance is stunning, yet vulnerable, beautiful, charming, witty, and sweet. A realistic love story with enchanting sweet romance that only Amy could portray but all can relate to. I must admit I've already viewed it more than once. I'm a new fan of Amy's thanks to her in this movie. Man or woman have a glass of wine sit back and enjoy the movie and then think about encounters in your past or maybe one you would like to have in the future! Fun, very sweet, very romantic and very enjoyable . . . a must see!!
21 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed