12 user 2 critic

The Wrong Girl (2015)

Fatal Friends (original title)
TV-PG | | Drama | TV Movie 16 May 2015
A budding friendship with a new student takes a sinister turn when the girl starts to disrupt the lives of her family.


Jason Bourque


Peter Sullivan




Cast overview, first billed only:
Jamie Luner ... Ashley Allen
Kirsten Zien ... Michelle (as Kirsten Prout)
Sarah Grey ... Sophia Allen
Nels Lennarson ... Dylan Allen
Dominika Juillet ... Hana
Alessandro Juliani ... Mr. Clark
Nicole Muñoz ... Allison
Aidan Drummond Aidan Drummond ... Alex
Josh Blacker ... Detective Jenkins
June B. Wilde ... Doreen
Colleen Winton ... Ellen Foley
Tricia Collins Tricia Collins ... Nurse
Tom Pickett ... Dean
Kane Tone Kane Tone ... English Student
Josh Byer ... Uniformed Officer


Sophia, a smart but quiet high schooler, strikes up a friendship with a new girl in class, but the girl begins to disrupt the lives of Sophia and her family. Sophia is then forced to uncover her friend's past and learn the truth before it's too late.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Plot Keywords:

tied feet | See All (1) »





Did You Know?


Also known as The Wrong Girl on Lifetime. See more »


Michelle sees Hana and a male student get into Hana's vehicle and the engine is heard starting as if they are going someplace. Michelle is pushing her bicycle. Later Michelle blackmails Hana with a photo showing her wearing the same outfit as earlier straddling the male student in her vehicle with the door open. Michelle on a bicycle would not have been able to keep up with the vehicle, and as such would not have been able to take the picture. See more »


Ashley Allen: It's just you know,
[brushes Sophia's hair with her hand]
Ashley Allen: your whole life revolves around school, and then practice, and then work.
Sophia Allen: Hmm. Mom. I'm healthy and I'm happy. And I promise on my way home I will get my head shaved, my nose pierced, and uh, I'm thinking a tattoo.
See more »

Crazy Credits

The closing credits include a spider: "Boris the Spider ... as himself" See more »


Big Band Blast
Written by Peter Allen
See more »

User Reviews

Bad Movie, Beautiful Women
19 May 2015 | by wes-connorsSee all my reviews

Before the opening credits, an institutionalized woman is electrocuted by someone we presume is the building's janitor. Classical piano plays as the credits roll and beautiful blonde Sarah Grey (as Sophia Allen) thrills her parents at a recital. As it turns out, Ms. Grey is lonely as well as beautiful. Hoping to attend Juilliard, she spends so much time practicing her piano pieces, Grey has little time for a social life. The church group friends mentioned do not appear. Neither does the church. Grey's loneliness is about to change. A new girl arrives at her high school. She is beautiful blonde Kirsten Prout (as Michelle Foley). Wearing a pair of dorky glasses to make her look less attractive, Ms. Prout takes an unusual interest in Grey. They quickly become "Fast Friends" (the working title), but you sense Prout is "The Wrong Girl". In fact, she may be a "Lifetime" TV movie psycho...

The only thing that could have saved this really, really stupid story would be a heavy dose of theatrical ham. Unfortunately, nobody is instructed to chew the scenery. Everyone is too distant. Director Jason Bourque and photographer Toby Gorman do best outdoors, with steady jogging and "pop quiz" lip-reading scenes. However, a chase scene involving police deciding to run after a bike-riding suspect, on foot instead of driving, is too absurd for words. Prout wearing glasses to look "plain" is like putting lipstick on a pig. While dressed to kill, Prout's an incredibly poor shot. Grey is stunning in her shorts. Prout and Grey are unconvincing in their roles as otherwise friendless high school teenagers. However, they sure look nice. Beautiful blonde architect mom Jamie Luner (as Ashley Allen) leads a subdued supporting cast. If "Beautiful blonde" was the only goal, they've scored.

*** The Wrong Girl (2015-5-16) Jason Bourque ~ Sarah Grey, Kirsten Prout, Jamie Luner, Nels Lennarson

9 of 14 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 12 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

See more »






Release Date:

16 May 2015 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

The Wrong Girl See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:




Aspect Ratio:

16:9 HD
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page

Recently Viewed