This film was originally going to be directed by Shawn Levy, but he left the project after disagreements with the Minecraft developers as they thought that his idea did not suit the game.
There are many references to Napoleon Dynamite, one of Jared Hess' earlier films such as the troublesome alpacas, the storing of tater tots in pants pockets, and the self-defense training dojo.
Jack Black was set to only appear as a cameo in the form of a talking pig, but due to the 2023 Hollywood labor disputes. Black taking over the role of Steve after Matt Berry had to vacate the role
This is the second collaboration between Jack Black and director Jared Hess, after Nacho Libre (2006), released 19 years prior.
Shortly after the first release of a teaser trailer, Minecraft creator "Notch" Persson expressed approval, having no apparent involvement in the film. He jokingly said "I probably would've even agreed to Uwe Boll making it." In 2014, Persson claimed there was an early concept film to be produced by Roy Lee and Jill Sobel Messick, which fell through some time after.