Following the attack at the museum, the FBI have identified at least 2 suspects, Luke and Mark. They also know Ryan has been conducting his own investigation and try, unsuccessfully, to get him to work with them. Mike Weston pushes Ryan to reveal his theory of how Joe managed to escape but Mike refuses to believe Joe is still alive. The FBI get a lead on Emma which leads them to arrested 6 of Joe's followers from the Havenport cult. Emma however wasn't there having made contact with Mark and Luke and decides to join them. The FBI tells Ryan to avoid anything related to the case or face arrest. He regrets having put Lily in danger but she appreciates his help and what he's done for her. Ryan begins to suspect someone. In Arkansas meanwhile, Judy returns home to find Rev. Glenn dead in her living room. She thought she had been a good influence on Joe but now wonders what she may have done wrong. Joe's not sure what to do about her after she pulls a gun on him but Mandy has a solution.