6.6/10
328
4 user 12 critic

A Rooftop in Gaza (2012)

Rock Ba-Casba (original title)
The year is 1989. In an era of Palestinian demands for independence, the State of Israel sends young soldiers to oversee the Arab population in the Occupied Territories. After one of them ... See full summary »

Director:

Yariv Horowitz

Writers:

Guy Meirson (screenplay), Yariv Horowitz (screenplay) | 2 more credits »
Reviews
6 wins & 9 nominations. See more awards »

Photos

Edit

Cast

Complete credited cast:
Yon Tumarkin ... Tomer
Roy Nik ... Aki
Henry David ... Ilya
Lavi Zitner Lavi Zitner ... Izac (as Lavi Zytner)
Yotam Ishay ... Ariel
Iftach Rave Iftach Rave ... Haim
Shmulik Chelben Shmulik Chelben ... Israel
Angel Bonanni ... Chaliba
Khawlah Hag-Debsy ... Samira (as Khawla Alhaj Debsi)
Adel Abou Raya Adel Abou Raya ... Muchamad
Karim Salama Ahmed Karim Salama Ahmed ... Walid
Vladimir Friedman ... Ilya's father (as Vladimir Fridman)
Rest of cast listed alphabetically:
Ofer Ruthenberg Ofer Ruthenberg ... Guard
Edit

Storyline

The year is 1989. In an era of Palestinian demands for independence, the State of Israel sends young soldiers to oversee the Arab population in the Occupied Territories. After one of them is killed, the common fate of four young soldiers and one Palestinian family is sealed. The film describes the extraordinary journey of a young soldier trying to find his place in the chaos surrounding him. Written by Yariv Horowitz

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Taglines:

Feature film

Genres:

Action | Drama | History | War

User Reviews

Thoughtful view on Israeli-Palestinian conflict in a small scale setting, observing from very close-by how people on both sides experience it
16 October 2013 | by JvH48See all my reviews

I saw this film at the Ghent (Belgium) film festival 2013, as part of the section Global Cinema. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is something we have seen in the news as long as I live, and I have given up on understanding what all this hostility and bloodshed is about. It looks like a stalemate situation without end. Even worse, since the word "settlements" made its appearance, I have the feeling that the conflict only seemed to escalate, with a peaceful solution getting farther away than ever before. Alas, the effect on the people involved does not get that much attention in the media. It was a reason for me to book tickets for this movie, in spite of it covering a topic that I usually avoid, usually arousing heated disputes even in the country where I live, not giving much hope for a sensible argument.

The synopsis on the festival website promised exactly aforementioned showcasing of the impact on "people in the street". After having seen this film I can only confirm that it lives up to these promises to its full extent. Though it seems to zoom in on one freshly arrived soldier in particular, it broadens its horizon very often, also involving the people around him on both sides of the metaphorical fence. And the fence is metaphorical indeed. I was very surprised to see poorly trained soldiers dispatched in the streets, armed with all sorts of heavy weaponry, but nevertheless relatively defenseless against local people who ambush them where possible and throw all sort of things to the soldiers.

The story begins when someone unknown drops a washing machine from the top of a house, killing one of the fresh soldiers at once. A group of his colleagues is assigned to guard the area using that same house as an observation post, thereby heavily interfering with the daily routine of the family that lives there. What they are trying to achieve from that spot, is not very clear because of the obvious fact (we can see with our own eyes) that the rooftop could easily be reached from other houses in the neighborhood. That is precisely the reason why the attacker who threw the washing machine in the first place, could get away with this action easily.

Soldiers and family involuntarily have to live together for some days, unwillingly forced to share the front door and stairs. The different attitudes on both sides get more prominent every day. Also, there are some among both sides who do not pull harmoniously together. That is precisely the beauty of this plot and the circumstances these people find themselves in. The soldiers are merely longing for the end of their engagement, their only purpose being to keep their heads low and not getting hurt in the process. The people living in the area just want to be left in peace, but also know how powerful they can be when joining forces against the intruders. The people try as much as possible to make the lives of the soldiers as difficult as possible, using ambushes, guerrilla tactics, or they just overpower soldiers on the street by their numbers.

All in all, a compelling plot and a perfect décor, precisely to show us what the synopsis of this film promised. We are in a perfect position to follow soldiers from very close by, at the same time also showing the citizens from a near distance. We are invited to feel along with both parties as much as possible from our safe distance. Extra complications that arise from language differences, are nicely demonstrated too, for instance when a young boy gets his hand on a grenade, just to play a "hands up" game he sees on television. I cannot identify myself fully with either party on the political level. Nevertheless I felt absorbed by the situation and how the story develops. No spoiler alert is needed when I say there is no happy ending. This movie ranked 18th for the audience award, with score 4.08 out of 5, still not bad but in comparison with the competition I think it deserved better.


4 of 5 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 4 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
Edit

Details

Country:

Israel | France

Language:

Hebrew | Arabic | Russian

Release Date:

21 February 2013 (Israel) See more »

Also Known As:

A Rooftop in Gaza See more »

Edit

Box Office

Budget:

$1,500,000 (estimated)
See more on IMDbPro »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Runtime:

Color:

Color
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page



Recently Viewed