When Maddy and Julia come face-to-face with a 'lovely' Tiara they're puzzled. Tiara has been WAY too nice lately, but the girls are willing to take whatever kindness they can get! That is until Maddy accidentally advises a guy at school to ditch his overbearing girlfriend, not realizing it's Tiara, and a whirlwind of chaos ensues. With a furious Tiara wreaking havoc at Baconsfield High, Maddy and Julia decide to set her up with another hunk in order to restore order. Only when they accidentally set Tiara up with Brody, it's not long before Tiara's domineering ways start to ruin Maddy's big brother's life! Knowing full well that if Brody dumps Tiara she'll ruin Maddy's life, Maddy and Julia give Brody a "make-under" and have him quit every one of the school's teams, turning him into such an unappealing durf that Tiara dumps him herself. Brody's thrilled, until he tries to return to normal and is horrified to discover he's completely lost his mojo. How can Maddy undo what she's done?!