Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory (2011)

A further followup of the case of the West Memphis Three and the decades long fight to exonerate them that finally gained traction with new DNA evidence.

Directors:

Joe Berlinger, Bruce Sinofsky

Stars:

Gary Gitchell, Todd Moore, Dana Moore

Nominated for 1 Oscar. Another 5 wins & 5 nominations.

Cast

Cast overview, first billed only:
Gary Gitchell	...	Himself - Former Chief Investigator, West Memphis Police (archive footage)
Todd Moore	...	Himself - Parent of Michael Moore (archive footage)
Dana Moore	...	Herself - Parent of Michael Moore (archive footage)
Pam Hobbs	...	Herself - Mother of Stevie Branch (archive footage)
Terry Hobbs	...	Himself - Stepfather of Stevie Branch
Melissa Byers	...	Herself - Mother of Christopher Byers (archive footage)
John Mark Byers	...	Himself - Stepfather of Christopher Byers
Damien Wayne Echols	...	Himself - Perpetrator (as Damien Echols)
Jason Baldwin	...	Himself - Perpetrator
Jessie Misskelley	...	Himself - Perpetrator (as Jessie Misskelley Jr.)
John Philipsborn	...	Himself - Post-Conviction Attorney for Jason Baldwin
Don Horgan	...	Himself - Post-Conviction Attorney for Damien Echols
John N. Fogleman	...	Himself - Prosecuting Attorney (as John Fogleman)
Mike Allen	...	Himself - Detective, West Memphis Police (archive footage)
Domini Teer	...	Herself - Suspect's Girlfriend (archive footage)

Storyline

In 1993, a horrific triple child murder was discovered in West Memphis, Arkansas, but the reaction to it precipitated a horror of its own. This film follows up on the story of the three boys, called the West Memphis Three, who were convicted for this crime with questionable evidence. For years, the boys' fate sparked a mass movement striving to prove their innocence while the state is equally determined to avoid admitting it could have been wrong. Through the swirl of new evidence and suspects, the Three tell their own tale about enduring this injustice against the opinions of the victim's families in a debate that eventually came to an inadequate resolution.

---

Plot Keywords:

west memphis three | injustice | arkansas | murder investigation | tattoo | 

---

Genres:

Documentary | Crime

---

Certificate:

Not Rated

Details

Official Sites:

HBO [United States] Official site

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Release Date:

13 October 2012 (Brazil)

Also Known As:

Elveszett paradicsom 3: Purgatórium

Filming Locations:

West Memphis, Arkansas, USA

Company Credits

Production Co:

RadicalMedia, Home Box Office (HBO)

Technical Specs

Runtime:

121 min

Color:

Color

Did You Know?

Trivia

Todd and Dana Moore, the parents of 8 year-old victim Michael, wrote a letter to the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences asking that the film be removed from consideration. In the letter they said that the film glorifies Damien Wayne Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley. Director Joe Berlinger had in fact acknowledged during an interview with salon.com that he determined Echols was innocent after speaking with him for five minutes prior to the trial. Despite the Moore's request(or perhaps because of it) the film was nominated for Best Documentary, Features for the 84th Annual Academy Awards. It lost to Undefeated (2011).

---

Quotes

Damien Wayne Echols: If I focused on the things I can't change, the things that have hurt me, what people have done to me, then they would have already broken me. They would have killed me inside and out. I can get up in the morning and I don't feel sorry for myself, I don't hate my life. You have a lot of people in here that all they can think about is what they don't have and how much they want out and how much they want something else. But for some reason, this situation has helped me to see more of what I do ...

---

Alternate Versions

The directors said that audiences at the Toronto International Film Festival in September 2011 would be the only audiences to see the film in that version. The reason is that events which took place the previous month necessitated a new ending to the film.

---

Connections

Follows Paradise Lost: The Child Murders at Robin Hood Hills (1996)

---

Soundtracks

The Day That Never Comes
Performed by Metallica
Written by James Hetfield, Lars Ulrich, Kirk Hammett and Robert Trujillo
Published by Creeping Death Music (ASCAP)
Courtesy of Elektra Entertainment Corp
By arrangement with Warner Music Group Film & TV Licensing

User Reviews

And Justice for None

This film is recommended.

The third installment of this documentary continues to explore the ever-changing case and testimony of three convicts who were convicted as teenagers in the brutal killing of three young boys in Arkansas. Due to the dedication and research of filmmakers Joe Berlinger and Bruce Sinofsky ( and recent DNA evidence ), the case was overturned and the three man were set free after nearly twenty years of incarceration.

Some background exposition: Known as the Memphis Three, Damien Echols, Jessie Misskelly, and Jason Baldwin were three wild teenagers back in 1994. The town and jury all but convicted them by their Goth appearance and love of heavy metal music. Questionable witnesses and a shaky confession obtained by police from one of accused sent them to prison.

Berlinger and Sinosky persevered, as did others who feel that the verdict was unjust. Thus, their first documentary, Paradise Lost: The Child Murders at Robin Hood Hills and Paradise Lost 2: Revelations kept the story and the hopes of the Memphis Three alive. This final chapter, Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory, brings this sad tale to a close.

While the film uses newsreel footage of the crime and court testimony, plus endless interviews with the accused killers and family members and townsfolk, the documentary tries to remain objective, but never really does achieve that status. The film presents allegations of jury misconduct and uncovered DNA samples that can link a family member to the crime, but it never investigates those findings with much clarity. ( The film also could have been more effective if it included more of the aftermath once Echols, Misskelly, and Baldwin were released, observing their individual choices once freed. )

Still, Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory does show the power of the documentary genre and the diligent efforts of the filmmakers to make a difference in the outcome of injustice. The tragic events that grew out of this heinous crime still linger with the families. ( One of the parents of the murdered boys asked the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Science to remove the documentary from consideration as they say the film glorifies their son's killers. The film remained in competition and is nominated for Best Documentary. ) Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory will linger with you too. GRADE: B

NOTE: Visit my movie blog for more reviews: www.dearmoviegoer.com