On Valentine's Day Indie receives a mystery red carnation with a note, and when she tries to find out who gave it to her, all signs point to her crush, Chad Tash! An excited Indie shows up to meet her secret admirer and is horrified to discover, not Chad, but Ram Ramachandran, who takes the date as a clear sign that they are now a couple. And he's not the only one. Apparently Medieval Club President, Rhonda, has been harbouring a crush on Ram for months, and she's not giving him up without a fight. She challenges Indie to a duel - medieval style. Is there any way to turn this situation around, let Ram down gently and get Chad's attention at the same time? Where there's an Indie, there's a way. Meanwhile, AJ and Chuck hold an anti-Valentine rally and discover that sometimes "true friendship" is all you need.