| Episode cast overview, first billed only: | |||
| Steve Carell | ... | Michael Scott | |
| Rainn Wilson | ... | Dwight Schrute | |
| John Krasinski | ... | Jim Halpert (voice) | |
| Jenna Fischer | ... | Pam Beesly (voice) | |
| B.J. Novak | ... | Ryan Howard | |
| Ed Helms | ... | Andy Bernard | |
| Leslie David Baker | ... | Stanley Hudson | |
| Brian Baumgartner | ... | Kevin Malone | |
| Creed Bratton | ... | Creed Bratton | |
| Kate Flannery | ... | Meredith Palmer | |
| Ellie Kemper | ... | Erin Hannon | |
| Angela Kinsey | ... | Angela Martin | |
| Paul Lieberstein | ... | Toby Flenderson | |
| Oscar Nuñez | ... | Oscar Martinez | |
| Phyllis Smith | ... | Phyllis Vance | |
Michael meets with an insurance salesman that visits the office and is later convinced by Dwight and Andy that he is part of the mafia.
From season 6 the show is falling apart, this episode is one of the dummiest content ever, who would believe that story to be true, seriously...