Allison and Joe are not only having to deal with the fact that Ariel seems to have a boyfriend but that if Allison's dreams are to be believed, that their daughter is dating a murderer. Much to Joe's annoyance - and to Ariel's horror - Allison jumps into this with both feet immediately involving Det. Scanlon and interviewing the boy, Casey Covington, at his school. As Allison's dreams continue, she becomes more convinced of the boy's guilt but can't quite make the facts fit. Bridgette meanwhile has taken to recording an inept neighbor's escapades and putting them on the Internet. It isn't so funny for Joe and Allison when they learn they are being sued.