Jesse meets Ethan, someone she could finally fall in love with, but then she meets Troy, and now she has a dilemma.


Daryn Tufts


Daryn Tufts, Daryn Tufts (story) | 1 more credit »





Cast overview, first billed only:
Christopher Gorham ... Ethan Reed
Alyssa Milano ... Jesse Young
Michael Landes ... Troy Parker
Carol Kane ... Barbara
Tom Lenk ... David Young
Beau Bridges ... Logan Young
Kelly Packard ... Suzy
Stephen Carey ... Matthew - Boy in Window
Paul Carey Paul Carey ... Paul
Maclain Nelson ... Club Host
Tayva Patch Tayva Patch ... Linda Young
Chris Clark Chris Clark ... Piano Player
Annette Wright Annette Wright ... Piano Bar Singer
Hannah McFarland Hannah McFarland ... Hayley
Chase Little Chase Little ... Conner


Jesse, in a moment of bold self-confidence, introduces herself to Ethan, a struggling writer. And then in walks Troy, and in a moment of bold self-confidence, he introduces himself to Jesse. Jesse falls in love with both men, who happen to have a lot in common but still seem very different. What will happen when Jesse has to tell the truth? Written by napierslogs

Plot Summary | Plot Synopsis


What would you do if you found your one true love... twice? See more »


Comedy | Romance

Motion Picture Rating (MPAA)

Rated PG for some mild thematic elements | See all certifications »

Parents Guide:

View content advisory »

Did You Know?


During the golf scenes (30 min, 1:24 min) there is a horizontal line across the set that delineates the foreground from the fake background. See more »


When Jesse visits Ethan's sister and her family for the first time her son can be clearly seen mouthing his sister's lines at the same time. See more »


Jesse Young: Favorite President?
Troy Parker: Rutherford B. Hayes.
Jesse Young: You can't just make up a name!
See more »

Crazy Credits

The credits are written inside a notebook by a male hand See more »


References The Sound of Music (1965) See more »


You're the Song
Written by Paul Jacobson
Performed by Paul Jacobson & the Madison Arm
Courtesy of Groundloop Records (ASCAP)
See more »

User Reviews

My rating is positive, its a nice film, although its a bit confusing, at times
26 October 2011 | by inkblot11See all my reviews

Rebecca (Alyssa Milano) lost her father when she was a youngster. Fortunately, her loving uncle (Beau Bridges) stepped in to help care for her and he's still looking out for her interests. Now a waitress in a cafe, Uncle stops in to encourage his stung-by-divorce niece to take a leap of faith and start dating again. She promises to try. Unbelievably, two men enter the cafe within 30 minutes, with requests for her phone number. One is Ethan (Christopher Gorham), a gifted writer who has just been told by his editor (Carol Kane) that his latest work will NOT be published. He is hurting and is contemplating a career change. Rebecca tries to cheer him up and does her job so well, that digits are exchanged. Not ten minutes later, another gentleman, Troy (Michael Landes), a rising ad writer, drops in for a carry-out order and ends up charmed by Becca, too, especially when she tells him how much she enjoys a certain ad he wrote. Again, Rebecca writes down her number. Over the course of the next few weeks, Becca's schedule is a whirlwind of dates and kisses. Ethan, poor as a church mouse, nevertheless takes her on picnics and hikes, even hustling Becca over to his sister's house. There, they all romp with Ethan's three active young nieces and nephews. Meanwhile, Troy entices Rebecca with fine dining, wine, and concerts. How ever will she choose between them? Also, to be honest, how can she string two men along, when its obvious both of them are getting very serious? This is a sweet film and an unusual story. Viewer, be prepared for a twisted ending that is satisfying but unexpected. Milano, very beautiful, is touching in the lead role while Landes, Gorham and the others do fine work, too. Romantic drama fans will also like the costumes, sets, script, photography and direction. Yes, the cover looks more like a romcom but, while there are funny moments, the story has a serious undertone. However, fans of romance should seek this one out before a new moon appears.

1 of 3 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 39 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.


Official Sites:

Official site





Release Date:

10 November 2012 (Belgium) See more »

Also Known As:

My Girlfriend's Boyfriend See more »

Filming Locations:

Salt Lake City, Utah, USA

Company Credits

Production Co:

fiftyfilms See more »
Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs




Aspect Ratio:

1.78 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page

Recently Viewed