Despite Sami's arrogant invasion of his bed, even ridiculing his favorite boxers, a gift from Will, Lucas remains calm and comforting when she stupidly hits her hothead ravaging his kitchen and proposes to share the bed- she refuses only till he clarifies that's sleeping only. Rex is in time to chase and catch the killer in the Lockhart Christmas tree stand, but Roman bumps into them, fearing Rex would hurt him, so he gets away, although shot and losing some blood. Mikey arrives to 'rescue' Bonnie, who fakes fainting and insists the rich bachelor should have eggnog at her place. Jan hesitates long whether to seizer the opportunity to kill rival Belle with the hammer she found or stay hidden and pursue her 'perfect plan' to get Shawn, deciding against the risk to be mistaken for the serial killer. Anyway, first Mimi returns, then the boys and each take their girl to bed, Jan is delighted to overhear Shawn is still a virgin.