In the opening of season two, Katie and Charlie are excited about the great deal they got on their brand new apartment. Katie is upset that Greg, the mattress guy from season one, has a new girlfriend, so the girls swap phones and set each other up for online dating. They head to a local bar to meet their choices for one another. Charlie has chosen Jordan, a deadbeat musician, and Katie has chosen Mike, an entrepreneur type. While these would be great choices for themselves, both girls are miserable with their date. After some exceptionally awful conversation, Katie and Charlie meet in the bathroom. Katie makes an out of character decision and Charlie supports it. In the end, Katie and Charlie are happy to be alone together.