In Tempe, Arizona in 1992 a young woman, Stacey Hendrickson, was reported missing and her apartment door was found kicked in. A neighbor across the hall looked through his peephole when he heard commotion and saw a man in front of her apartment, banging and kicking on her door, but the neighbor didn't call the police. For the next few days, the police search for Stacey, but she is nowhere to be found. Stacy's Father, Raleigh Hendrickson, who lives in Toledo, Ohio, joins up with local psychic, Gale St. John. Her visions lead police to their primary suspect, John Barry Adams, who later admits that he was trying to commit suicide but Stacey got shot accidentally. Gale St. John's psychic gifts lead police to the body and the murder weapon, but the discovery of the weapon leads police to suspect Adams' story and forensic evidence paints a very different picture of the events leading to Stacey's Death.