A hit-and-miss anthology that starts well but does not sustain it, and it suffers from uneven timings and clunky mood changes.
The first story, about Samhain, is spoiled by characters mispronouncing 'Samhain', some unconvincing effects (probably to avoid depiction of a child beating an adult to death), repetitive script, irregular continuity, and some bizarre colour balance. The opening drone shot would be excellent were it not for light saturation, then scenes inside the house are washed out in reds and browns. A violent scene offscreen is rendered amateurish by entrails apparently thrown into view before being snatched back. A character plays a tape at loud volume but sits down a metre away and the music is all but silenced.
An undead story doesn't really go anywhere but mixes speech with telepathy randomly. Once it is established that characters are reading each other's thoughts, slipping back to speaking seems pointless.
An 'Indian burial ground' story is a mess. Names are stressed as if important when they are not; reference to Indians as "feather, not red dot" feels borderline racist but disrespectful anyway. Events take place a year apart, but without any idea what a character might have been doing during that time. The story is not developed and is an opportunity wasted.
The serial killer story loses its way and tries to be too many things, none of them well, and the nun story just wants to be something else. Jump cuts, jumbled timeline, unexplained characters and questionable motivation make it feel more arthouse horror than snappy short.
A lengthy credits sequence includes cast and crew for five stories not in the version I saw. Research tells me these were trailers for other films but all content has been edited out other than the closing credits. With only five stories in the film itself, this sequence could have been half the length.
The first story could have been made into a 90-minute standalone feature but the rest do not sit well together and offer no progression. The bookending by 'Malvolia' is unnecessary, but a running theme or transition story might have helped. Major edits following trial screenings would have been advisable.
