Episode complete credited cast: | |||
William Hartnell | ... | Dr. Who | |
William Russell | ... | Ian Chesterton | |
Jacqueline Hill | ... | Barbara Wright | |
Carole Ann Ford | ... | Susan Foreman | |
![]() |
Derek Newark | ... | Za |
![]() |
Alethea Charlton | ... | Hur |
![]() |
Eileen Way | ... | Old Mother |
Jeremy Young | ... | Kal | |
Howard Lang | ... | Horg |
The TARDIS takes its new passengers back to the dawn of history. There, the Doctor and his party are captured by a tribe who are trying to rediscover the secret of fire.
Review for episodes 2, 3 and 4.
Following on from the brilliant opening episode the remainder of the '100,000 BC' story is a slight disappointment.
It is not remotely bad as it has interesting elements and is of good quality in all respects but it is somewhat ill conceived to start the series with a story set in a prehistoric world with cavemen and their squabbles over the discovery of fire.
Any criticism that the story is not correct historically can be answered in that it is not specified that the setting is actually Earth. It could, therefore, be another planet at a time of caveman civilization. Also, criticisms of how cavemen could converse in English are explained because later on in Doctor Who we are told that the Doctor's time machine - the TARDIS - allows the travellers to converse with aliens or people speaking other languages via some sort of telepathic means. However, it is somewhat less interesting and somewhat more confusing for viewers of the day than if they had an opening serial featuring alien beings or a more suitable human era such as recent past or the future.
The discovery of fire story with tribal in fighting is not really typical of the series to follow and does not afford good guest characters or sufficiently intelligent plot to get really into it. There is some very annoying screeching and grunting at times and the cavemen or somewhat lacking in interest. There is, though, a lot more intelligent scripting and interest provided with the Doctor and his companions. Their characters begin to be fleshed out and their relationships begin to develop. That aspect of the story is very good.
Overall this is good but could have been better with aliens instead of cavemen.
My Ratings: Episode 2 - 7.5, Episode 3 - 7.5, Episode 4 - 7.