Jerry scores premium tickets to a New Jersey Devils playoff game. He invites Kramer, Puddy, and Elaine along. But Jerry gets weirded out when Puddy shows up at the game and paints his face to match the team colors. Puddy gets so worked up after the game that he freaks out a visiting pastor from El Salvador, who is convinced that Puddy really is the devil. Elaine tries to convince him otherwise. Kramer enjoyed the game so much that he tries to convince Jerry to get more tickets from the guy Jerry got them from. Meanwhile, George decides to tell his girlfriend that he loves her, only to have the plans backfire on him while Kramer battles a chimpanzee at the zoo.
Jerry gets tickets to a Rangers-Devils playoff game from Alec Berg, someone he and Elaine dislike. When George opts not to go Elaine gets Jerry's okay to bring her boyfriend Puddy. No is quite prepared for Puddy's level of enthusiasm however. George didn't go to the game so he could keep a date with his new girlfriend Siena. He decides to take a leap of faith and tells her he loves her. Her response is not quite what he was hoping for. When Jerry fails to call Berg the next day to thank him, he suddenly finds himself getting the cold shoulder.
- Elaine (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) dates David Puddy (Patrick Warburton) who paints his face in New Jersey Devils colors before each hockey game. Kramer (Michael Richards) gets into a fight with a monkey at the zoo. George (Jason Alexander) debates whether to say I love you to a woman.