In the present, someone tries to murder Detective Marjorino by running him over with a car in a dark alley that will send him straight to the hospital. Will is on the scene and accompanies the detective in the ambulance. Back in 1995, Samantha and Craig set Will up for a blind date with Katherine Clark. The four of them have supper at Samantha and Craig's loft. Will and Katherine seem to hit it off. But Will's smile will soon vanish when he learns more about Katherine's family... Meanwhile, Carla gets a proposition she can't refuse. Aaron and his wife, Pascale, go to couple's therapy. Also, Jenna learns one of Brad's secrets.