Gilmore Girls (TV Series) So... Good Talk (2005) User Reviews

Superb ending

[rich-fouts · 10/10 · 2 October 2022]

Lorelei and Luke aren't speaking, Lorelei isn't speaking with Emily, but Rory and Logan are warming up and getting it on.

Richard tells Emily that although she met well, she really messed up by coming between Luke and Lorelei. Emily is furious, but when she calms down she does the right thing, goes to the diner and tells Luke, "you won, go to her."

Meantime, Lorelei resorts to movie night, by herself, by renting all three Stars are Born.

When she gets to the Judy version, the doorbell rings while Judy is belting out The Man That Got Away. While we fear she might burst into tears, she answers the door, and there's Luke. No talk, just a big dramatic kiss while Judy is singing, " ... the writing's on the wall." Fade to black.

Good Talk

[ISmellSnow · 7/10 · 12 January 2021]

Sookie tries to have a girls night with Lorelai but she's very pregnant and can't do any of the fun things that she used to. Luke is being a grouch to customers and it's hilarious. Rory stands up to Emily. Luke and Lorelai kiss :)

This is where Lorelai becomes unbearable.

[m-47826 · 1/10 · 19 July 2023]

Luke dumped Lorelai, because she lied about seeing Christopher behind his back! Not because Emily tried to play matchmaker between Chris and Lorelai. Which eventually backfired, and didn't change anything, until Luke learned about Lorelai's secret meeting with Chris. And the fact that she lied about it. You're following? I am so sick of the way writers twist things around, and make it look like Emily was responsible for Luke and Lorelai's breakup. And why should she be? Are they ten, and need an adult's consent to see each other?! Lorelai brought it on herself and whines about it, and point fingers at her mother as usual, and obviously poisons her daughter's mind. The way Rory talked to her grandmother, made me want to slap her across the face. And Luke is such a jerk! He's the one who's decided to break up, so why be mad at the whole world now? I am officially sick of this couple and can't wait for them to part ways for good. The level of toxicity they create, for something they both caused, is unbelievable. Lane and Zack are lame, I don't like them as a couple either.