Nick becomes upset because Shelly is always at the apartment he shares with her boyfriend, J.T. Shelly eats the guys' food and generally interrupts their manly pursuits, but J.T. doesn't mind. After Nick and Shelly's feud reaches a climax at J.T.'s birthday party, J.T. begs his friends to reconcile. Meanwhile, suspecting that former model Rita is returning to her anorexic ways, Janie tries to tempt her with her secret weapon: Janie's homemade lasagna. And Donovan competes with a rival to create the perfect signature drink for his club.