"Doctor Who" The Greatest Show in the Galaxy: Part One (TV Episode 1988) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A great opener, a really imaginative story.
Sleepin_Dragon21 January 2019
I love the opening episode, it has such a rich content, it's an episode that plays on a fear many people have, clowns. Why create a new alien race, when we have clowns, when used to good effect, they make the most terrifying menace of all. Not a huge deal of threat in this one, it's mainly implied, this episode gives you a taster for what's to come, it introduces some terrific characters. I absolutely love The Captain played by T.P. McKenna and Peggy Mounts stall keeper, two marvellous actors.

It's typical eighties sci fi horror, the monster shooting rays, and the terrific bus conductor. Some really nice special effects, and a definite energy, all make for a terrific opening episode.

It's not a full house though, Nord and Adrian Mole are both very irritating, and the music is maybe a little cumbersome. All in all though, I really enjoyed it. 8/10
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not the Greatest Story in the Galaxy of Who (but far from the worst)
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic30 November 2019
Review of all 4 episodes:

There are interesting ideas in this story as well as dark, macabre content which is a real strength. Sadly the budget, lack of technology, time constraints, production problems and the bad taste of the era lead to the potential not being reached in my opinion.

The first 2 parts of the story, especially the first part, are reminiscent of the previous season's horrible pantomime feel mixed with a surreal nightmare. The production is like a farcical, weird stage play with odd, anachronistic characters and settings, bizarre situations, embarrassing scenes of action, some zany dialogue and dodgy effects. There is a slight Neil Gaiman feel with a dark, gloominess merged with crazy surrealism and it holds enough fascination and potential to stop it sliding to the low levels of Season 24. Once it gets to Part 3 things pick up and Part 4 is much much better. To some extent the weirdness of the story is explained away by the psychic elements and the suggestion that at least some of the odd goings on are perceptions projected by the villains who turn out to be the 'Gods of Ragnarok'. These later episodes lift the whole story but do not totally wipe away some of the inadequate scenes, silly characters and rather lame acting.

The final part especially is ghoulish fun with creepiness and humour mixed together. McCoy does his full vaudeville style clown/W.C. Fields act while strange, scary clowns and gothic villains threaten imminent death.

You could not accuse this of being boring or ordinary, it is striking and different and has ideas which with more care and budget could have been a twisted classic. As it is, this is a reasonable effort but not as successful as it could have been.

My ratings: Part 1 - 5.5/10, Part 2 - 6/10, Part 3 - 7/10, Part 4 - 8/10. Overall - 6.63/10.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Greatest Show in the Galaxy: Part One
Prismark109 September 2023
The title of the show came from producer John Nathan-Turner. The Greatest Show in the Galaxy could stand for Doctor Who itself.

Once the best sci-fi show going once but time has not been kind to it. People routinely mutter that it's not as good as it used to be.

With dwindling audiences, it is now frequented by riff raff or nerds. The Doctor and Ace visit the psychic circus on the planet Segonax courtesy of junk mail received by the Tardis.

They encounter galactic traveller Captain Cook (T. P. McKenna) and his companion Mags. Only this traveller might be the selfish kind.

This story by rights should not exist. It was meant to be shot in BBC Studios which had an asbestos scare. Director Alan Wareing looked to book studio space at alternative studios only to find none available.

Finally quickly improvising with time running out. A circus tent was erected at the car park of BBC Elstree studios and there was enough time left to shoot the story.

The tent was a masterstroke, giving it a claustrophobic atmosphere. It also enabled outdoor filming allowing Ian Reddington to stand out as the creepy clown.

An interesting first episode, but like a lot of McCoy stories. It always never gels properly. The creepy clown is balanced out by the shouty, thuggish Nord on a motorbike. Actor Daniel Peacock showing his lack of range once again.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"I don't believe it, junk mail that talks back." OK Doctor Who episode.
poolandrews1 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Greatest Show in the Galaxy: Part 1 is set on the distant planet of Segonax where the Doctor (Sylvester McCoy) & his companion Ace (Sophie Aldred) have decided to land & check out the Psychic Circus dubbed the greatest show in the galaxy, once there the Doctor gets a strange feeling, a feeling of evil. The Doctor & Ace make their way to the circus, meanwhile two performers named Bellboy (Christopher Guard) & Flowerchild (Dee Sadler) are heading in the opposite direction as they try to escape the circus but are hunted down by a couple of sinister clowns, Bellboy is caught & taken back to the circus where something evil is happening & the Doctor is walking straight into it...

This four part Doctor Who adventure was the last story from season 25 & this first part was episode 11 of that particular season & aired here in the UK in late 1988, directed by Alan Wareing I wouldn't call this great Doctor Who. I have to mention the title of this story The Greatest Show in the Galaxy, as the opening credits end & the title comes up it says Doctor Who The Greatest Show in the Galaxy & I have to say I wondered whether the writer Stephen Wyatt was trying to be clever, trying to be funny or just being ironic, you decide. Anyway, as it stands I thought this episode was OK, like all TV shows the first episode sets the situation up & deliberately doesn't try to give too much away as to try & get the viewer to tune in next week. Unfortunately The Greatest Show in the Galaxy didn't really hook me or interest me that much if I'm honest, very little actually happens apart from the Doctor & Ace trying to find the circus itself & meeting a few people along the way. The highlight of this episode is the Doctors encounter with a killer robotic bus conductor! This story seems to be taking itself quite seriously which I'm not so sure is a good idea considering the material & production values.

The budget was obviously tight & again the production values when viewed today hurt the programme overall, special effects this bad like the terrible cardboard looking robot that attacks Mags (Jessica Martin) just kills dead any tension or suspense that a story such as this could have developed. There are no monsters or aliens in this episode unless you count a couple of robots.

The Greatest Show in the Galaxy: Part 1 is an OK Doctor Who episode, it isn't as fun as the best Doctor Who stories & to be honest I'm hoping for better as the story progresses, bring on Part 2...
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good story.
tonygarraway20093 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
After the rather hit and miss nature of Sylvester McCoy's first season, there was a definite upturn in his second season, and this story is no exception.

Clowns play a big part in the story, and in this case they are sinister with a definite malevolent streak. A special mention must go to Ian Reddington's portrayal of the Chief Clown. The actor seems to have made a conscious effort to make the character as interesting as possible and it works very well indeed.

TP McKenna is also memorable as the inter-galactic explorer Captain Cook. The character seems to spend most of the story sipping cups of tea while others are in mortal danger. The Captain appears to be quite a jovial type but is actually rather an unpleasant man who is only interested in self-preservation.

Visually the story looks good, with a Dorset quarry working very effectively as the hot and barren wastes of the planet Segonax. As studio filming was not possible due to an asbestos scare, all the sequences involving the Big tent had to completed on location. I feel that this unplanned situation actually makes the story better than it may otherwise have been.

With mysterious gods, a bit of hippie culture and clowns driving a hearse thrown in for good measure, I consider the story to be one of the more successful productions of the late 80s Doctor Who.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
When it's this poorly executed, it cannot be anything else but rubbish.
fad-3879826 June 2020
Start off with a circus, trot out the tired old trope of 'something evil', cue killer clowns and set it in a quarry.

Add a lacklustre couldn't be bothered script, poor direction and terrible acting.

The doctor has a very limited range but does even less than usual in this story, Ace is the usual mid-twenties thespian 'acting' the role of a teenager. It doesn't work, the character comes across as a bit of an idiot.

Another example of why the programme (in this form) was cancelled, and rightly so.

Yes, I accept that some see currency in the 'it could have been more', "could have been a better programme with better funding" etc. Sadly, we have what we have, and it's crap.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Weak sauce
Leofwine_draca26 April 2015
Review of the Complete Story:

THE GREATEST SHOW IN THE GALAXY is a weak adventure for the seventh Doctor, a case of "make it up as you go along" in terms of plotting and narrative intrigue. The storyline sees the Doctor and Ace arriving on a barren planet, where a sinister circus showcases new acts from across the galaxy. Inevitably, something sinister lurks behind the grinning smirks of the clowns, and the Doctor has to find out what it is.

Oh dear. The premise itself sounds cheesy and it turns out that this serial is just as you'd expect it to be: cheap looking, cheesy, very lightly written and with not a lot going on in it. In a bid to counter these problems, plenty of supporting characters are added to the mix, but none of them are very interesting and the acting is substandard, to say the least.

Sylvester McCoy is still a hoot as the Doctor and Sophie Aldred isn't too annoying in this one. What THE GREATEST SHOW IN THE GALAXY does have going for it is a ton of familiar faces including T. P. McKenna (STRAW DOGS), Ricco Ross (ALIENS), TV actor Ian Reddington, Peggy Mount and even a chap from LOVEJOY. There are a few fun sections here and there, such as the encounters with a deadly robot, but the production has been noticeably "kiddified" and much of it consists of dull characters rambling on or people running around in a quarry. It's hardly 'classic' Who...
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Not for the Coulrophobic
JamesHitchcock29 July 2015
During my childhood in the sixties and seventies clowns were simply funny men who made people laugh, but since the eighties these once innocent symbols of light-hearted entertainment have taken on an increasingly sinister role in popular culture; the Evil Clown, who hides a malevolent nature behind his smiling mask, has become a stock character in horror films and stories. A pseudo-academic word, "coulrophobia", has even been coined to denote a morbid fear of clowns, although the "coulro-" element does not correspond to any Greek root.

Coulrophobes would be well-advised to avoid "The Greatest Show in the Galaxy", which has a circus theme. The Doctor and Ace pay a visit to the planet Segonax to see the fabled Psychic Circus, despite the fact that Ace is something of a coulrophobe herself. On arrival, however, they find that something very odd has happened to the circus. There are only three other members of the audience, a father, mother and their young daughter, who all appear to have stepped out of a fifties timewarp. This family, however, appear to have the power of life and death over those appearing in the circus ring; those whom they judge to be insufficiently entertaining are executed on the spot. We make the acquaintance of several more eccentric characters, including the famous intergalactic explorer Captain Cook, his eccentric female companion Mags, who turns out to be a werewolf, and the Circus's eccentric Ringmaster. And, of course, several Evil Clowns. The Doctor and Ace, assisted by those few surviving members of the Circus staff who still hold the quaint old- fashioned belief that boring one's audience should not be a capital crime, try to uncover the sinister power which has seized control of the Circus.

Sylvester McCoy's Seventh Doctor will never be my favourite, but this serial is certainly a lot better than some others from his era, such as its immediate predecessor "The Silver Nemesis" or "The Curse of Fenric" from the following year, both of which attempted to cram too much plot (in the case of the largely nonsensical "Fenric", far too much plot) into a short space. "The Greatest Show in the Galaxy" avoids this mistake by concentrating on a single plot line. It has its own logic, albeit a weird, surreal logic, and makes a sort of sense on its own eccentric terms.

One Doctor Who spin-off novel asserts that the Gods of Ragnarok, who appear in this serial, also created the Land of Fiction, which features in the Second Doctor story "The Mind Robber". Such novels are regarded as being of doubtful "canonicity" by most Who fans, but I can see the logic behind this idea. These two serials, separated chronologically by about two decades, have a lot in common with each other, being more surreal fantasy than hard-core science fiction and playing games with the concept of reality. The idea of a circus on an alien planet, frequented not only by a Time Lord but also by a robotic bus conductor, a female werewolf, three mysterious gods, several Evil Clowns and an "intergalactic explorer" who actually looks less like a spaceman than a Victorian jungle explorer, down to the pith helmet, seems like some nightmarish vision out of a painting by Dali or a modern Hieronymus Bosch.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed