Laura throws Rob a surprise birthday party. After everybody has left to go home, Rob can't find the new expensive watch Laura bought for him as a gift. Rob and Laura turn the house upside down but can't find the watch. Although neither wants to believe it, both come to the conclusion that the most logical explanation is that one of their friends at the party - Jerry, Millie, Buddy, Sally or Mel - stole the watch. The most obvious culprits are Jerry or Buddy as the pranksters, but both deny pulling any such prank or any knowledge of the watch's whereabouts. As Rob and Laura try to find out what happened to the watch, all their friends come to know what is in Rob and Laura's minds, although Rob and Laura say they don't suspect any of the five as having taken the watch. The situation gets even worse when Rob tries to salvage some monetary value of the watch by collecting the insurance money. Laura and Rob come up with a plan both to salvage their friendships and to find out if any of ...
Did You Know?
When the insurance man leaves the Petrie's home, Laura mouths the word "night" but there isn't any audio. See more
Millie, uh, could I speak to Laura a minute, please?
Well, of course. You can't very well talk behind my back to my face, can you?