A jealous Angelique uses witchcraft to prevent the marriage of Barnabas and Josette Du Pres by casting a spell to make Josette fall in love with Joshua. Meanwhile, Victoria and Josette are both stunned by the similar appearances with each other. When Barnabas finds out about Josette and Joshua running off to elope, he purses them where a deadly duel ensues. Due to the strange happenings, the paranoid Abigail only grows more suspicious of Victoria. In the present day, Elizabeth, Julia and the rest of the family deal with the presence of the ailing Phyllis while trying to find a way to bring Victoria back to the present.