Tiffany suffers recurring nightmares about driving to a castle on a rainy night and seeing a dark-haired woman in a wheelchair pushed down a flight of stairs. She goes to visit her college friend Erica. She is stunned to discover that Erica's house is the same one from her nightmares, and Erica confesses that she detects a sinister presence. Erica's husband, Clifford, dismisses the whole thing as nonsense. Kelly and Kris arrive the next day, and Tiffany explains what has happened. They are surprised to learn from Erica that Tiffany was found to be sensitive to the paranormal in a test. A car with no driver apparently tries to run down Erica and Tiffany. Tiffany talks with Clifford's staff - an old married couple - and learns that he was previously married. His previous wife, Madeleine, was a brunette confined to a wheelchair because of polio. She was murdered during a masquerade party, supposedly by an escaped convict who stole her engagement ring; but her killer was never captured. Mrs. Craig believes that Madeleine doesn't like the idea of another woman living in her house and is trying to drive Erica away. Clifford and Erica's party that night is to be the first in the house since the killing. Tiffany fears that something terrible will happen after she sees Erica, who suffered a sprained ankle escaping the car, in a wheelchair.
While Tiffany talks with Kris and Kelly, the windows suddenly open and the bed shakes. Lights begin selectively turning on and off, and Tiffany suspects that Madeleine wants to be followed. The ghost lights a secret passageway and leads Tiffany to a storage room, where she finds Madeleine's engagement ring with the diamond missing. Kris finds her, and Tiffany explains that Clifford killed his wife and sold the diamond. Kelly tries to keep an eye on Erica, but Clifford distracts her and takes Erica back upstairs. Tiffany and Kris race off to try to save Erica; the ghost holds the kitchen door closed so that Tiffany will have to go upstairs. Clifford leaves Erica alone for a moment, and then returns in a skeleton costume and tries to push her down the stairs. Tiffany arrives and cries out, alerting Erica. She eludes Clifford, who falls down the stairs and dies. They learn that Clifford killed at least two young wives for their insurance money.
This is definitely an excellent episode.Despite the fact that it tries to be horror in genre and spooky in nature,we get to see more development in Tiffany's character as having some sort of a paranormal and psychic abilities as well as being the bravest, smartest, nicest and most resourceful Angel.Also,what makes it different from an episode similar to this entitled Haunted Angels is that all the ghost that are involved are pretty much of a scam.But this time,there is no scam available.In fact,the ghosts were helpful in solving the mystery involved.Finally,I get to like the humor involving Bosley when he doubted the existence of Madeline for in this episode the ghost are definitely legit and helpful.