Caroline's home town of Peshtigo, Wisonsin decides to dedicate a park to her. As Richard is the only person available, he accompanies her back to Peshtigo. Caroline's brother, who is a surgeon, also returns home and there is some intense sibling rivalry. Even the dedication doesn't go well. Annie gives her role to her understudy so that she can dance in front of her parents. But Annie has second thoughts when she thinks the understudy is after her position in the 'Cats' chorus line.