One Step Beyond (1959–1961)
6 user

Make Me Not a Witch 

A farm girl's parents are terrified when their daughter reveals that she can read minds. But a priest knows that her gifts can save two young lives.


John Newland


Merwin Gerard (creator), Gail Ingram | 1 more credit »

Watch Now

With Prime Video



Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Episode cast overview:
John Newland ... Himself - Host
Patty McCormack ... Emmy Horvath
Robert Emhardt ... Priest
Eileen Ryan ... Mrs. Horvath
Leo Penn Leo Penn ... Jed Horvath
Deena Goldstone Deena Goldstone ... Jill Riley (as Deena Gerard)
Jimmy Baird Jimmy Baird ... Captain Riley's Son
William Greene William Greene ... Captain Riley
Pedro Regas ... Juan Orriba
Preston Hanson Preston Hanson ... Doctor
Charlotte Knight Charlotte Knight ... Housekeeper (as Charlott Knight)


Emmy Horvath, a farm girl, innocently reveals to her mother and father that she can read their minds and the minds of others. She takes her ability for granted, but her psychic power terrifies her parents, who worry that she'll be condemned as a witch and taken away from them. Emmy flees to an unfamiliar church, where she prays, "Make me not a witch." A priest sees her and persuades her to tell him her secret. She does, but makes him promise to tell no one. Later, a fisherman turns up on a beach. The fisherman knows that two children are trapped alone on an island, but which one? The old man's paralytic stroke prevents him from being able to tell anyone. The priest, who has been called to the fisherman's side, knows that the one person who can enter the old man's mind is the girl with the paranormal gift. Written by J. Spurlin

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Not Rated




Release Date:

22 December 1959 (USA) See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:

Mono (Westrex Recording System)

Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See full technical specs »

Did You Know?


[first lines]
Mrs. Horvath: Emmy, time to set the table.
See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

The Good Seed
14 March 2010 | by wes-connorsSee all my reviews

Twelve-year-old farm girl Patty McCormack (as Emmy Horvath) rattles her parents by telling them she can read some folk's minds. Father Leo Penn (as Jed) and mother Eileen Ryan think their daughter could be condemned for witchcraft. They forbid Ms. McCormack use her telepathic powers. McCormack is unhappy with her supernatural abilities. Going to church, she pleads with God, "Make Me Not a Witch!" There, McCormack meets priestly Robert Emhardt, who wants to use her mind-reading power to locate some missing children. Obviously, the priest's own God line is on the fritz.

Well, this is the place for seeing "The Bad Seed" (1956) star McCormack (rather too mature for twelve, though) in an uncharacteristically sweeter role, the sometimes villainous Mr. Emhardt in a priestly robe, and Mr. and Mrs. Penn as the parents.

In real life, the latter couple parented actors Chris and Sean Penn. Sean looks a lot like his mom, don't you think?

**** Make Me Not a Witch (12/22/59) John Newland ~ Patty McCormack, Robert Emhardt, Leo Penn, Eileen Ryan

2 of 5 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 6 user reviews »

Contribute to This Page

Stream Trending TV Series With Prime Video

Explore popular and recently added TV series available to stream now with Prime Video.

Start your free trial

Recently Viewed