The aftermath of the dinner party has many Cedar Cove residents in a state of denial. Olivia and Jack confront each other about their trust issues. Then, Olivia is concerned after Grace calls off her engagement, even as Grace insists she is fine with her decision. But Bob and Peggy secretly plan to prove she is only kidding herself. Then, as Olivia serves Will papers to stop his real estate plans, some unsolicited advice from Paul makes her second guess her decision.