6.7/10
267
7 user 34 critic

Wall (2004)

Mur (original title)
Not Rated | | Documentary | 26 August 2005 (USA)
A meditation on the separation fence in Israel-Palestine that imprisons one people while enclosing the other.

Director:

Simone Bitton

Writer:

Simone Bitton
3 wins & 1 nomination. See more awards »

Photos

Edit

Storyline

A meditation on the separation fence in Israel-Palestine that imprisons one people while enclosing the other.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Plot Keywords:

meditation | See All (1) »

Genres:

Documentary

Certificate:

Not Rated | See all certifications »

User Reviews

Fine human interest documentary
23 September 2004 | by jim9tanSee all my reviews

This documentary provides an even handed examination of the long Wall that the Israelis are building in Palestine. It allows the people living there to speak for themselves.

While the situation is bad for the Palestinians, it is equally appalling for Israelis on the front line. The documentary doesn't attempt to explore solutions.

It examines the personal and cultural costs of severing the Israelis from the Palestinians. Often, the long term social consequences are at odds with the short term political aims. Can the Israelis regain their sanity? Can the Palestinians find compromise? This is one of the defining struggles of the 20th Century.

Postscript November 2005: It is unfortunately that some people don't understand the film's POV. The film-maker chose to focus on the presence of the wall (being built) and its human consequences. This documentary is not about the Arab-Israeli conflict (which stretches back to the British Mandate and earlier); nor about who is right or wrong. That is why it is entitled "The Wall", and not "The Intifada".

Why has she chosen to ignore the roots of the conflict? One obvious reason is that any discussion of politics leads to polarization, which obscures the reality of human suffering.

The Internet is such a powerful enabler. It's a pity that it cannot bestow instant wisdom on IMDb commentators.

Postscript May 2006: What is a documentary? One definition is "A film or TV program presenting the facts about a person or event".

Therefore, a documentary has to be non-fictional. Does a documentary have to be analytical? Would a long look at the Wall serve us better than a recital of the antagonists' cases?

In the western tradition, there is a clear sense of right and wrong. We attain enlightenment through a careful analysis of the facts. The truth allows us to judge a case and declare for one claimant over another.

This judgmental approach works when there is a clear difference between right and wrong. For example, the Nazis had to be opposed because they turned German nationalism (rational) into the pathology of ultra-nationalism (irrational). In retrospect, the Nazis are roundly condemned for the consequences of their pathology, though there is blame enough for those who did not oppose the rise of ultra-nationalism.

Western rationality fails in the case of a tragedy, where right opposes right. That is, the right of the Israeli State to exist against the right of displaced Palestinians to return home. No analytical documentary can help us here. No legalist judgement can deliver a 'fair' verdict.

What is the intention of the film-maker? The Wall itself is the symbol of the pathology that has sprung up in the Palestinian-Zionist conflict. Perhaps, empathy will transcend judgement, race, ideology and hatred. Is that focused enough?


16 of 22 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 7 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
Edit

Details

Country:

France | Israel

Language:

Arabic | Hebrew

Release Date:

26 August 2005 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

Il muro See more »

Edit

Box Office

Opening Weekend USA:

$4,015, 28 August 2005

Gross USA:

$14,541

Cumulative Worldwide Gross:

$56,866
See more on IMDbPro »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Runtime:

| (Buenos Aires Festival Internacional de Cine Independiente)

Sound Mix:

Dolby

Color:

Color

Aspect Ratio:

2.35 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page



Recently Viewed