This movie barely captures the essence of Craigslist and does a mediocre and, frankly, boring job of it at that. Most of the time is spent on the shock value of 4-way gay orgies and things of that nature--things that have been occurring long before CL and have little to do with the site and community other than that's how this particular gay-guy-gang-bang happened to organize itself.
What about all us regular folk who find apartments, jobs, sports teams, even entire networks of friends on CL? Yes, the film brushed by that, but with some very boring and typical stories. What about those of us who have started entire businesses on the Internet and couldn't have done it without Craigslist? Or someone who really made a big difference in someone else's life because of CL? You know those stories are out there. My life is the extraordinary product of some of them.
This is an amateur film (doesn't really even deserve the perceived value of "indy") that chose to focus on the freakish, predictable and boring aspects of a web site that has revolutionalized economies and markets and done an unquantifiable amount of good in millions of peoples' lives. I wouldn't be surprised if this film inspires a more talented and creative film maker to one-up this poor offering.