By Hook or by Crook chronicles the tale of two unlikely friends who commit petty crimes as they search for a path to understanding themselves and the outside world. Silas Howard plays Shy (... See full summary »


Harry Dodge (as Harriet Dodge), Silas Howard


Harry Dodge (as Harriet Dodge), Silas Howard | 1 more credit »
7 wins. See more awards »





Credited cast:
Silas Howard ... Shy
Harry Dodge Harry Dodge ... Valentine
Stanya Kahn Stanya Kahn ... Billie
Carina Gia Carina Gia ... Isabelle
Rest of cast listed alphabetically:
James Cotner ... Attacker
Joan Jett ... News Interviewee
Kris Kovic Kris Kovic ... Crazy Nut in Park
Maia Lorian ... Parasol Girl
Tina Marie Murray ... Ms. Red
Aldo Pisano Aldo Pisano ... Driver
Nancy Stone ... Waitress


By Hook or by Crook chronicles the tale of two unlikely friends who commit petty crimes as they search for a path to understanding themselves and the outside world. Silas Howard plays Shy (a transgender man), who leaves his small town after the death of his father, and heads to the big city to live a life of crime. Along the way, he encounters Valentine, a quirky adoptee, in search of his birth mother. An immediate kinship is sparked between these men and they become partners in crime. Suffering money troubles, emotional problems, and physical confrontations, the duo face their issues head on and learn to trust each other and support each other in pursuit of their goals. Written by azr

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Crime | Drama | Romance


Not Rated

Did You Know?


Valentine: Did you ever hear about those monks, who just walk around real slow and careful, and they're careful about everything, and they don't step on any bugs, and the main thing is that they don't hurt or kill anything their whole lives?
Shy: What's your point?
Valentine: Well... we're just hitting lots of bugs all the way along here.
See more »

Crazy Credits

The film is "dedicated to Kovic." (Kris), who also plays the part of the "old man in park." See more »


Featured in Fabulous! The Story of Queer Cinema (2006) See more »


Over The Edge
Written by The Mono Men
Performed by The Mono Men
Courtesy of Au Go Go Records
See more »

User Reviews

Remember those names
7 February 2006 | by The HoykSee all my reviews

A good and trusted friend asked me to watch this with her, and I am very glad she asked me and that I did. Now that's going to sound funny when I go on to say that I don't think this movie really works, but stay with me. And keep in mind I'm an essentially straight male watching a film geared almost exclusively to butch lesbians, so my opinion may seem worthless anyway.

I'll start with the faults. It's crudely cut, paced too leisurely, and it's basically insular and a little too in love with itself; it's coasting on the charisma of it's lead characters to make up for the fact that there is little real meat to this movie. The story lines involving lost fathers and petty crime seem underdeveloped and tacked-on for the sake of having something, anything to drive what little plot there is.

But, the strengths begin front and center with Harry Dodge. You can't take your eyes off when Dodge is on screen, the presence is that magnetic. And the dialogue that's been created in tandem with partner Silas gets you interested in them. And yes, while I criticized the lack of solid ground for a story, the characters kept my interest throughout.

What I am saying here is that I felt a sizzle in the same manner that I felt when I saw the first works of Alison Maclean or Katja von Garnier, or what critics in the '50's felt watching the first Cassavettes or Godard. Like those early debuts, this film by itself is not accessible to a 'regular' audience, but the talent and potential is obvious and exciting, and as a viewer I become quite interested in seeing their next film. In fact, I think if I were a producer watching this, I would want to bankroll their next film the same way Mel Brooks took a gamble on David Lynch.

So yes, by my friend corralling me into watching this, I got to walk in on the ground floor of what should be an exciting film-making team. With the right balance of impulse and discipline, I think Silas Howard and Harry Dodge are going to create something big in the future.

7 of 7 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 15 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.






Release Date:

17 June 2001 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

By Hook or by Crook See more »


Box Office

Opening Weekend USA:

$1,802, 27 October 2002

Gross USA:


Cumulative Worldwide Gross:

See more on IMDbPro »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:



See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page

Recently Viewed