In early versions of the script, the character of Evan was originally Chris Treborn. When the "T" is moved over, it becomes "Christ Reborn". This was changed to Evan Treborn, which is a play on "Event Reborn".
During one of Evan's "flashback" scenes, he can be heard reading part of Ray Bradbury s short story "A Sound of Thunder". In this story, a group of people travel millions of years into the past to hunt dinosaurs. One of them accidentally steps on and kills a butterfly, which dramatically alters the future.
Elden Henson shot all of the later "normal" scenes with his character first because he had to gain around twenty pounds in one month for the later timelines in which his character is crazy. He was to look bigger as crazy Lenny and thinner as normal Lenny. To the filmmaker's amazement he accomplished this.
The lights flicker in the background of the psychiatrist's office when Evan is being hypnotized, after they blew up the mailbox. This was not a planned special effect - it was an actual short in the wiring on set. The directors thought it fit well with the scene and used that take in the final cut of the movie.
The title is a reference to a concept in Chaos Theory whereby small events may lead unpredictably to large events. This is explained in the opening quotation which explains that a butterfly flapping its wings may result in a typhoon. It may also be seen secondarily as a reference to the short story, "A Sound of Thunder", by Ray Bradbury.
Evan's diaries have the same cover layout as the diaries of John Doe in Se7en (1995), also released by New Line Cinema. They are standard composition notebooks that are used by school children across the country every day.
The main character, Evan, wrote a total of ~4745 entries from age 6 to age 19 (basically 365 days x 13 years). Therefore 4745 entries divided by 192 pages(front/back) in a standard notebook would take up ~24 notebooks in this movie.
The trivia items below may give away important plot points.
There are four alternate endings. In the first, Evan turns around and talks to Kayleigh at the same time. In the second, Evan turns around after Kayleigh has already turned around, and follows her. In the third ending, Kayleigh turns around first and then Evan turns around and Kayleigh walks away. Evan stands there for a minute then walks away and does not follow Kayleigh. In the fourth one, Evan watches a home movie of his birth, rather than him meeting Kayleigh. He travels into the movie, and strangles himself in the womb. (This can be seen at the end of the Director's cut.)
Evan's mother makes mention of having previous late term miscarriages before Evan was finally born. This information does more than just set the stage for the alternate ending in which Evan watches his birth video and strangles himself in the womb. It also adds intrigue as to whether these were natural events, or if perhaps Evan had siblings who suffered the same fate, and decided to end their own lives just before being born.
The scene where Evan has no arms was achieved by using two shots: one with an empty bed, and one with Ashton Kutcher lying in the bed with green gloves on his hands (which were erased later). Both shots had identical camera movements. For most films, this would be achieved by using machine-controlled cameras, which can replicate the exact same movement for multiple takes. However, since this film was fairly low-budget, the filmmakers were not able to afford this kind of equipment and the two identical shots were achieved by manually moving the camera while using a stopwatch for reference. Any small changes in the two shots were fixed digitally in post-production.
The movie's title screen is a scan of the brain (as shown from the front). The left and right lateral ventricles of the corpus callosum (the middle of the brain) in this picture are displaced. Such is the case with many schizophrenic patients. The displaced ventricles in the middle of the brain are sometimes referred to as looking like a butterfly. In the movie, Evan is not schizophrenic, but in the next to last universe he "jumps" to (after he accidentally kills Kayleigh as a child), he is treated as if he is; the doctors tell him that everything that happened to him throughout the course of the movie was made-up.
In the original ending, Evan travels back through time to the day of his birth and he commits suicide in his mother's womb as an unborn baby. That ending was used in the director's cut. The film was given a different ending in the theatrical version and the conclusion of the film was changed to Evan traveling back through time to the day he met Kayleigh when he was child and he upsets Kayleigh when he tells her that he hates her and her family and threatens to kill her and her family if she comes near him again. Evan did this because he felt the only way for him and his family and close friends to be happy with their lives was to avoid befriending Kayleigh and let them live their lives without affecting Kayleigh or her troubled, protective brother Tommy.
In the scene where Evan and his mother are standing at Jason's grave, Kayleigh comes up and takes Evan's hand. We don't know what she says to him because of the distance of the shot and the score playing in the background. She actually says: "you're probably better off now."
During Evan's penultimate flashback (the one after which he wakes up in the mental hospital), there is a quick succession of shots with people making funny faces. One of the people appearing on several pictures is co-director Eric Bress.
There is a scene where the alternate reality is created where Evan finds himself at College as a fraternity brother. When we see his memory being 'rebuilt' we see Kayleigh hitch a ride to visit Evan at age 13 after he moved away. People don't realize (and it's not even mentioned in the DVD commentary) that the driver is Karl, the bald prisoner who would exist in that reality before going to the same prison as Even.
Aside from appearing for a split second in a picture during the last-to-final flashback, co-director Eric Bress also appears as a patient in the mental hospital in the beginning of the movie. In the alternate ending on the director's cut, he also has a cameo as Andrea's new husband (in the alternate time line created by Evan).