User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
It made me laugh
planktonrules8 February 2019
I love watching silent comedies and have seen thousands. Because of that, while a film like "Something in Her Eye" might not impress the average person if they saw it, I realized that for 1915 it was very funny stuff....even if the plot is incredibly contrived.

A lady is walking home when she gets something in her eye. She keeps blinking it...and guys think she's making a pass at them! Soon, three suitors show up at her front door!! But her father is a protective sort and he does what any slapstick dad would do in 1915...he starts shooting his gun aimlessly towards them. But when the lady informs her dad that they want to marry her, he gives chase because he wants to get her married! What's next? See the film.

This short stars a young Oliver Hardy over a decade before he'd become teamed up with Stan Laurel. He is fine and the film made me chuckle. However, some of the reactions were ridiculously over the top--typical of 1915 but silly when seen today.

By the way, the actress 'Billy Rhodes' is a fake according to IMDB and the lady pretending to be Ms. Rhodes isn't her at all! This sort of thing was NOT uncommon in the day and there were quite a few fake Charlie Chaplins as well...and the most famous of them, Billy West, made quite a few films with Oliver Hardy as well.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Babe and Trixie
boblipton31 August 2012
Vim goes the flirting-in-the-park route with this one-reel comedy. Actually, it starts out with Trixie Gale -- with a question-mark-shaped beauty mark on her cheek -- attracting the usual types, wends its way through a farce as her suitors hide from her father in a French farce manner and then fight for her hand, ending with her running away with Oliver Hardy.

The only reason this picture survives at all is that Hardy is in it and it's interesting that he has a lot of his mannerisms this early, sped up enormously. Although the emphasis is on the gags rather than the plot, it is clearly modeled on the Arbuckle-Normand comedies from Keystone that were so popular at the time. Neither lead has the presence of their models, but of course things would change for Hardy.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed