Fi runs into an old friend, Bricriu, while a friend of Molly's and her daughter Annie visit. After Fi says a spell out of her spell book everyone but herself and Annie turn into animals or plants. Fi makes a decision to protect her family. While Annie's mom asks a favor of Molly.
Molly decides to sell the old house and move closer to town. Jack, Annie, Carey and a couple of friends spend a night with a Ouija board. When the Ouija board starts to predict the future Annie tries to prevent a disaster.
As "Annie" was worried about being late for college after spilling a drink over herself, she soon then discovers that Molly Philips started getting mail from "Annie" who at the same time was also in "Washington DC". The only other solution that Annie could see was that another "universe" had collided with their own which allowed the two Annie's to intertwine with one another.
In this clip show episode, Ziegler from "Exit 13" gives Annie a package, containing a spell that makes the gang lose their memory about Annie. Annie tries to refresh everyone's memories using anecdotes from their past adventures.