The Thick-Walled Room (1956) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Kobayashi's study of a world gone mad
TheHighVoltageMessiah17 April 2013
"Kabe atsuki heya" (or "The Thick-Walled Room") was the third film of director Masaki Kobayashi, who would go on to make such masterworks as "The Human Condition", "Hara-kiri", and "Samurai Rebellion". In "The Thick-Walled Room", one can see many of the elements Kobayashi would use to greater effect in those later films – the sense of political consciousness, the criticism of corruption within society, and the focus on human failings.

The film takes place four years after the end of World War II, and concerns a group of low-ranking Japanese soldiers imprisoned by the Americans for war crimes. It soon becomes clear that these people are small fry, forced into their actions by their superiors and doomed to take the fall for the actions of the army. Meanwhile, their superiors, who are shown to be brutal and actually bear most of the guilt, manage to escape unscathed.

As you can imagine, this subject matter was considered most controversial during the time the film was being made. The studio, afraid the film would offend Americans, demanded the film be severely cut. Kobayashi refused to do this, and so the film was shelved for three years. Although completed in 1953, it did not come out until 1956. Then it was lost in obscurity once again – that is, until the Criterion Collection finally released it on DVD as part of its Eclipse Series. At last, as of April 2013, "The Thick-Walled Room" can be widely seen.

Of course, the film isn't as polished as Kobayashi's greatest work, and it is clear that at this point he was still maturing as a filmmaker. But there is, nevertheless, a lot that is very good about this film. The prisoners are not depicted as wronged saints but as fallible human beings. They can be arrogant, deluded. They have tempers. They can be cruel to one another. The backstories and histories of these characters are also quite well-handled. Through these histories, Kobayashi is able to broaden his scope and analyze the after-effects of the war all across Japan, and not just focus on the goings-on inside the prison. One example of how Kobayashi does this is when one of the prisoners recollects a girl he met during the war. He is infatuated with the memory of her, idealizing her innocence and purity, and has hopes of settling down with her if he ever is set free. But the prisoner's brother, who comes sometimes to visit him, knows the hollowness of these fantasies. That innocent girl has grown into a cynical prostitute. Her character makes a bitter remark on the state of the nation that rings throughout the film: "The war made us insane. And we're still insane."

"The Thick-Walled Room" is an interesting study of degradation and corruption in postwar Japan. It is also compelling for what it shows about Masaki Kobayashi's early career. Hopefully, now that the film is more readily available, more people will have the chance to see it.
22 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
nope
treywillwest11 August 2016
One of the few films to deal with one of the twentieth century's most overlooked atrocities: the imprisonment and mass killing of Japanese foot soldiers during the post-war American occupation. After the genocides of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the US conspired with the Japanese monarchy and political establishment to blame the crimes of Japanese fascism on the lowest ranked soldiers who were acting under orders from their now-accusers.

The film does a nice job of naturally switching from a collective protagonist of various imprisoned "war criminals" to a more conventional, individually focused narrative of revenge. It's slightly sentimental notion that the worst of humanity is punished simply for having to be itself is made more palatable by its hauntingly wretched presentation of the real war criminals. These are characters who hate themselves, each other, and yet laugh at anyone taking a higher path.

On an unintentionally funny note, the actors playing the American guards have such thick EurAsian accents that their "English" is just about indecipherable. Every once in a while, it's healthy to see your own nationality poorly stereotyped.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of very few.
eri-kb4 June 2019
Very few films, if any, tackle the subject of the mostly innocent "war criminals" from the war in Japan with the subject of Accountabilty being the focus. As with others on here, yes you can definitely see the makings of a great director here and what he worked on to become that. Does this mean that the director's style in progress take away from what's here? Absolutely not.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed