5.3/10
110
4 user 6 critic

Swann (1996)

Rose Hindmarsh finds herself at the centre of a controversy when she meets author Sarah Maloney as she investigates the life of Mary Swann, an obscure poet who was brutally murdered in a small town in rural Ontario.

Director:

Anna Benson Gyles

Writers:

Carol Shields (novel), David Young
Reviews
5 nominations. See more awards »

Photos

Edit

Cast

Cast overview, first billed only:
Brenda Fricker ... Rose Hindmarch
Miranda Richardson ... Sarah Maloney
Michael Ontkean ... Stephen
David Cubitt ... Brownie
Sean McCann Sean McCann ... Homer
John Neville ... Cruzzi
Sean Hewitt ... Morton Jimroy
Kyra Harper ... Jean
Meg Hogarth ... Mrs. Cruzzi
Suzanne Coy ... Publisher
Joyce Gordon ... Rose's Friend
William Lynn William Lynn ... Rose's Friend
Lynne Deragon Lynne Deragon ... Brownie's Assistant (as Lynn Deragon)
Reiner Schwarz Reiner Schwarz ... TV Interviewer
Michele Muzzi Michele Muzzi ... Bookstore Fan
Edit

Storyline

Rose Hindmarsh finds herself at the centre of a controversy when she meets author Sarah Maloney as she investigates the life of Mary Swann, an obscure poet who was brutally murdered in a small town in rural Ontario.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Genres:

Drama | Romance

Certificate:

See all certifications »
Edit

Details

Country:

Canada | UK

Language:

English

Release Date:

7 March 1997 (UK) See more »

Also Known As:

Das Geheimnis der Mary Swann See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Runtime:

Color:

Color
See full technical specs »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

dead poets
10 April 2004 | by petershelleyauSee all my reviews

That the director of this feature has a background in documentaries is not surprising given that the treatment is character rather than plot driven, however as a piece of drama it fails.

The main problem is that nothing really happens, or rather Anna Benson Gyles and screenwriter David Young allow any potential action to wither away. The set-up has potential, with the murder of a Canadian poet and the introduction of Sara Moloney (Miranda Richardson), an American commissioned to write an investigative biography which irks Rose Hindmarch (Brenda Fricker), the local librarian. There is a mystery to unfold, however one that does not involve the poet's killing, which flashbacks suggest, and even a subplot with the lover of the American writer and another involving cancer don't have any impact. If the director is trying to parallel a tone with that of poetry reading, her climax is counter-productive. These are poems we never want to listen to. The film's best part is a flashback over a fish-soiled manuscript, even if accompanied by a voice-over of what we see.

There are narrative contrivances such as having Sara listen to opera as she works (!), and bemoaning the theft of her computer when she has barely made notes. However there is some humor. The dead poet Mary Swann is described as "She was not exactly a yacker". When asked if Sara thinks Mary was a marginal person, she replies "I guess that depends where you think the center is". And there is a laugh over fans distaste as they are served typical food Swann would have eaten at the library's symposium.

Another major problem is with the performances of Richardson and Fricker, who never connect. They compete in acting reflectively, with Fricker the winner since she isn't as verbally mannered as Richardson is here. Richardson displays a physical poetry that Fricker lacks, for example in the way she walks down a hallway with an injured knee, however she cannot put sugar in her tea without over-acting it.

Presumably the figure of Mary Swann is fictional, however her doomed countenance in black and white photographs suggest far more than what is delivered here. No wonder poets think they are never appreciated in their lifetime.


3 of 6 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 4 user reviews »

Contribute to This Page

Stream Trending Movies With Prime Video

Enjoy a night in with these popular movies available to stream now with Prime Video.

Start your free trial



Recently Viewed