9 user 7 critic

Gesualdo: Death for Five Voices (1995)

Tod für fünf Stimmen (original title)
Works, legend and murders of Carlo Gesualdo, a notorious Italian composer and murderer from the 16th century.


Werner Herzog


Werner Herzog




Cast overview, first billed only:
Pasquale D'Onofrio Pasquale D'Onofrio
Salvatore Catorano Salvatore Catorano
Angelo Carrabs Angelo Carrabs
Milva Milva ... Self
Angelo Michele Trorriello Angelo Michele Trorriello
Raffaele Virocolo Raffaele Virocolo
Vincenzo Giusto Vincenzo Giusto
Giovanni Iudica Giovanni Iudica
Walter Beloch Walter Beloch
Principe d'Avalos Principe d'Avalos
Antono Massa Antono Massa
Alan Curtis Alan Curtis
Gennaro Miccio Gennaro Miccio
Silvano Milli Silvano Milli
Marisa Milli Marisa Milli


Works, legend and murders of Carlo Gesualdo, a notorious Italian composer and murderer from the 16th century.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Did You Know?


Referenced in Sweet Pain (2019) See more »

User Reviews

F is for Fabrication in Five Voices
7 September 2012 | by chaos-rampantSee all my reviews

We really do change a lot. Two years ago this was another Herzog-story on creative madness to me, one of many small ones he has done.

I saw it this time with insights from a classically trained musician friend, and myself steeped in observation of storybased limits in Wagner as well as Italian Futurist writings from the 1910's about chromatic -abstract- harmony, among other things on disharmony I have been looking into.

The piece is deceptively simple: disguised as documentary truth, we have, pieced together from several narrators, a short story on madness, tormented love, and musical genius that transcends the holy (from the time before Bach). And if the musings of the rough-hewn caretaker of the ruined estate can be safely waven off as tall folk legend, the by all means respectable director of the Gesualdo institute projects confidence, as he looks up from his stack of papers, that he is recounting an account of actual history of things as they happened.

We go on to visit places central in events of that story, as well as closely examine some of the trinkets of drama: the actual bed where murders took place, the gruesomely displayed skeletons "most likely" those of illicit lovers.

Other narrators are much more obviously unreliable than would satisfy truly fine limits between reality and fiction, but even so, many viewers have come out of this confused. It seems, from the perspective that this is really an account, a gross miscalculation on Herzog's part to include the obviously set-up bit with the supposed mad opera singer, interjecting staged eccentricity in the midst of truth. Not at all.

The point is that down to the original - judicial - account, we only have testimonies and conjecture, and we can plainly see from testimonies Herzog has gathered in the course of the film, how difficult it is to surmise the real thing from stories about it. We come out of this with slight variations on the portrait of a man, with dissonance between the voices telling the story. The only truth left is in the music, excerpts of which are marvellously conducted for us.

And how stupendous, that music - offered to god - is about slight dissonance between different voices, each one harmonical within itself, but the whole has subtle disharmony that is its own chromatic truth in the face of the harmony of logic, and that truth is we are dissonant beings.

If you thought Herzog's recent Cave of Dreams was too ordinary, look again. It's about the same dissonance in our narrative devices.

4 of 4 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 9 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.





German | Italian | English

Release Date:

1995 (Germany) See more »

Also Known As:

Death for Five Voices See more »

Filming Locations:

Italy See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Sound Mix:




Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page

Holiday Movies on Prime Video for the Whole Family

Prime Video has you covered this holiday season with movies for the family. Here are some of our picks to get you in the spirit.

Get some picks

Recently Viewed