Cast overview, first billed only: | |||
Ian Richardson | ... | Sherlock Holmes | |
David Healy | ... | Dr. John Watson | |
Thorley Walters | ... | Major John Sholto | |
Cherie Lunghi | ... | Mary Morstan | |
Joe Melia | ... | Jonathan Small | |
Terence Rigby | ... | Inspector Layton | |
Clive Merrison | ... | Bartholomew Sholto | |
Richard Heffer | ... | Thaddeus Sholto | |
![]() |
John Pedrick | ... | Tonga |
![]() |
Michael O'Hagan | ... | Mordecai Smith |
Robert Russell | ... | Williams | |
John Benfield | ... | McMurdo | |
![]() |
Moti Makan | ... | Lal Rao |
![]() |
Kate Binchy | ... | Maid |
Gordon Rollings | ... | Mr. Sherman |
Hired by a young lady, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson investigate the strange recent deaths of her missing father's friends from the army, as well as the whereabouts of the Great Mogul, the second-largest diamond in the world.
Although in some parts not too faithful to the original story this is a good Holmes adaptation. Everyone involved is making a good effort and the the finished product is solid enough.
One thing I did definitely not like is the way Tonga was presented. I am aware that he was portrayed as "so deeply marked with all bestiality and cruelty (and that) his small eyes glowed and burned with a sombre light, and his thick lips were writhed back from his teeth, which grinned and chattered at us with half animal fury" (quote from the original story). I'm sure I can't apply 21st century political correctness to a 19th century story but the scenes where Small fed his companion with raw meat in an earth hole were definitely not necessary in a 1983 production.
Still, this being the only thing that bothers me a bit, this is a great movie. Ian Richardson comes close to my idea of Holmes and is second in line for my favourite Holmes, Brett AND Rathbone being in the fist place.