User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
That's entertainment!
In 1972 and '73, film critic Richard Schickel made an 8-part series for American public television: 'The Men Who Made the Movies'. Each episode featured a prominent Hollywood director discussing his career in an on-camera monologue (actually an interview, with Schickel's questions edited out), interspersed with generous clips from his most famous films, accompanied by somewhat overwrought narration (written by Schickel and spoken by Cliff Robertson). It's regrettable that Schickel did not include Billy Wilder in this series, as Wilder was alive and quite voluble at the time.

A coffee-table book was published as a companion volume to this series. More about that book later.

For those people who merely enjoy movies as entertainment without particularly caring about film theory, the segment featuring Vincente Minnelli is the most enjoyable and accessible instalment in this series. Unlike the other seven chosen directors, Minnelli specialised in musicals, so several of the film clips in this documentary are complete musical numbers (not excerpts), such as 'The Night They Invented Champagne' (from 'Gigi') and 'That's Entertainment!' (from 'The Band Wagon'). These delightful sequences are still very enjoyable as shown here, taken out of their original context; the other seven directors in Schickel's series primarily made dramas (or, in Frank Capra's case, non-musical comedies), and the excerpts from their films do not work nearly so well out of their original context. We do see a clip here from 'The Band Wagon' in which several tech cues go wrong during a Fred Astaire routine; out of context, it's not immediately clear that the errors are part of the film's story, and are intentional.

Although this documentary is about Vincente Minnelli, there are inevitably several film clips featuring his wife and muse Judy Garland ... including the slapstick scene from 'The Pirate' in which she assaults Gene Kelly. Thankfully, Schickel's script and the interview footage deal entirely with Minnelli's film career, with no gossip about his marriage to Garland nor their daughter Whatsernose.

The second half of this documentary features a clip from a dramatic film, depicting Frank Sinatra and Shirley MacLaine running through a funfair's midway while an unseen gunman fires at them. Oddly, Robertson's narration entirely neglects to identify this movie: a painful lapse, as this is one of Minnelli's most atypical films. The companion book, fortunately, amends this lapse and several similar omissions throughout the series. The unidentified film is 'Some Came Running'.

We also see a clip from the ballroom sequence of 'Madame Bovary', in which the footmen shatter the windows while Jennifer Jones dances. I found this situation dramatically implausible, but Minnelli stages it brilliantly.

I wish that this excellent documentary had raised the subject of Minnelli's notorious obsession with detail. Elsewhere (not here), Frank Sinatra has recalled how Minnelli delayed the filming of the midway sequence in 'Some Came Running' for several hours while he tried to figure out what displeased him about the location. Eventually, Minnelli decided to have the Ferris wheel moved a very slight distance ... at great expense and more delay. On an earlier occasion, Minnelli shot countless wasteful retakes of the bathtub sequence in 'Yolanda and the Thief' because he wanted Lucille Bremer to crook her arm at precisely the proper angle to frame a grotesque statuette behind her head, which she couldn't see. (Nowadays, a video monitor would enable the actress to do this in one take.) Minnelli's artistry is manifest in his beautiful films, but sometimes he really did seem to overdo it.

All eight episodes of 'The Men Who Made the Movies' are well-made, highly entertaining and informative, although they tend to concentrate on the most well-known (and most typical) films of their respective subjects. Despite a few flaws, I'll rate all eight episodes of 'The Men Who Made the Movies' a perfect 10 out of 10.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this
10/10
BEST Minnelli interview! VERY Entertaining and informative.
kentad9 March 2002
An in depth look at the films and creative process of Vincente Minnelli. MUCH deeper than the breezy rapid fire clip approach of films like That's Entertainment. Certainly the most coherent, technical and enjoyable interview with the master in the comfort of his home. Some of the clips were used very effectively later in the show Minnelli On Minnelli. This is better. Minnelli directly addresses the camera and is well cut over clips from many of his amazing movies. He explores his own inspiration, decision making process and pays a loving and very generous tribute to the immense gifts of his former wife, Judy Garland. Humor, intelligence and the magic of moviemaking are all highlighted in this glimpse of The Man Who Made Those Wonderful Movies. This is a hard to find title, but 16MM and VHS copies do exist. Other great Hollywood Directors covered in this series include Alfred Hitchcock, Howard Hawks, Raoul Walsh, Frank Capra, King Vidor and more. Also turned into the book The Men Who Made The Movies. The other episodes and the book are also HIGHLY recommended.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? | Report this

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews