7.2/10
101
2 user 3 critic

Israel, Why (1973)

Pourquoi Israël (original title)
A documentary examining life in Israel twenty-five years after the birth of the state.

Director:

Claude Lanzmann

Writer:

Claude Lanzmann
Reviews
1 nomination. See more awards »

Photos

Learn more

More Like This 

Documentary | History
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.1/10 X  

A place: Theresienstadt. A unique place of propaganda which Adolf Eichmann called the "model ghetto", designed to mislead the world and Jewish people regarding its real nature, to be the ... See full summary »

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Benjamin Murmelstein, Claude Lanzmann
Documentary | History | War
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.3/10 X  

A gripping account of the prisoners uprising at the Nazi extermination camp of Sobibor in 1943.

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Yehuda Lerner, Francine Kaufmann, Claude Lanzmann
Napalm II (2017)
Documentary
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 5.4/10 X  
Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Claude Lanzmann
Tsahal (1994)
Documentary
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 6.6/10 X  

A documentary about the Israel Defense Forces.

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Ehud Barak, Avigdor Feldman, Shlomo Gazit
Lights and Shadows (Video 2008)
Documentary | Short
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.5/10 X  

At the occasion of the sixtieth anniversary of Israel, Claude Lanzmann made an interview of Ehud Barak, on March 1st, 2008.

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Ehud Barak, Claude Lanzmann
Documentary
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.3/10 X  

An interview with a WWII Red Cross official who wrote a glowing report on a Jewish ghetto-cum-death camp.

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Maurice Rossel, Claude Lanzmann
Shoah: Four Sisters (TV Series 2018)
Documentary | History
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.8/10 X  

Four interviews done in the 1970s with women who survived the Holocaust.

Stars: Claude Lanzmann, Paula Biren, Ruth Elias
Shoah (1985)
Documentary | History | War
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 8.6/10 X  

Claude Lanzmann's epic documentary recounts the story of the Holocaust through interviews with witnesses - perpetrators as well as survivors.

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Simon Srebnik, Michael Podchlebnik, Motke Zaïdl
The Karski Report (TV Movie 2010)
Documentary
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 7.2/10 X  

An extended interview with Polish resistance fighter Jan Karski, consisting largely of footage gathered for but not included in Claude Lanzmann's epic 9-hour documentary "Shoah".

Director: Claude Lanzmann
Stars: Jan Karski, Claude Lanzmann
Drama
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 6.4/10 X  

In 1957, Elise Le Tellier, a young woman from Bordeaux, decides to join her brother Lucien, a revolutionary who has decided to become a worker instead of a notable. Lucien has secured a ... See full summary »

Director: Michel Drach
Stars: Marie-José Nat, Mohamed Chouikh, Bernadette Lafont
Night and Fog (1956)
Documentary | Short | History
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 8.6/10 X  

The history of Nazi Germany's death camps of the Final Solution and the hellish world of dehumanization and death contained inside.

Director: Alain Resnais
Stars: Michel Bouquet, Reinhard Heydrich, Heinrich Himmler
Drama
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 4.6/10 X  

A beautiful summer day. A garden. A terrace. A woman and a man sit at a table beneath the trees, with a soft summer wind. In the distance, in the vast plain, the silhouette of Paris. A ... See full summary »

Director: Wim Wenders
Stars: Reda Kateb, Sophie Semin, Jens Harzer
Edit

Cast

Credited cast:
Jacques Barkat Jacques Barkat ... Himself
Schmuel Birger Schmuel Birger ... Himself (as Schmuel Bogler)
Ran Cohen Ran Cohen ... Himself
Mikael Feldman Mikael Feldman ... Himself
Simha Flapan Simha Flapan ... Himself
Gad Granach Gad Granach ... Himself (as Gert Granach)
Beno Grünbaum Beno Grünbaum ... Himself
Paul Jacoby Paul Jacoby ... Himself
Claude Lanzmann ... Himself - Interviewer
Dolf Michaelis Dolf Michaelis ... Himself
Baruch Narshon Baruch Narshon ... Himself
Zushy Posner Zushy Posner ... Himself
Léon Roisch Léon Roisch ... Himself
Leon Rouach Leon Rouach ... Himself
Avraham Schenker Avraham Schenker ... Himself
Edit

Storyline

A documentary examining life in Israel twenty-five years after the birth of the state.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis

Genres:

Documentary

Edit

Details

Country:

Italy | France

Language:

English | German | Hebrew | Russian | French

Release Date:

October 1973 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

Israel, Why See more »

Filming Locations:

Israel See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Sound Mix:

Mono

Color:

Color

Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See full technical specs »
Edit

Did You Know?

Connections

Featured in Claude Lanzmann: Spectres of the Shoah (2015) See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

 
Because
17 August 2010 | by GrandeMargueriteSee all my reviews

"Pourquoi Israël" ("Israel, Why", without a question mark) is Claude Lanzmann's first documentary. Lanzmann is famous for his most prominent work, "Shoah", a lengthy yet powerful and unforgettable history of the Jewish genocide during WWII. "Pourquoi Israël" examines life in Israel twenty-five years after the birth of the state.

Lanzmann said that he was in Germany to study philosophy when the Jewish Agency became the Provisional government of Israel in 1948, therefore not at all aware of what was going on in Palestine. Not a fervent Zionist himself, Lanzmann is nevertheless haunted by what makes Jewish identity and anything related to this topic. It is interesting to note that Lanzmann started to shoot footage for "Pourquoi Israël" right after writing "Elise, ou la vraie vie" ("Elise, or Real Life" -- see that entry) which was a film on the Algerian war. Indeed, it may seem a little odd that someone who is clearly against colonialism would support the survival of Israel, but Lanzmann takes on a non Manichean approach (I wouldn't say "objective", that's something else) when he depicts the achievements and contradictions of the Israeli nation. Through a series of scenes, where the director spends time with many different people (German-Jewish migrants, dock workers, intellectuals, police, prison inmates, and the newly arrived -- especially from Russia), Lanzmann shows that the normality of a "state like any other" is actually abnormality itself. "How peculiar is a place where there are Jews and nothing but", he once stated in an interview.

Is "Pourquoi Israël" "Shoah" before "Shoah"? Yes and no. It is already a lengthy collection of interviews (it lasts almost three hours; that's short by Lanzmann's standards), but it has a faster pace, some mise-en-scene here and then and, yes, some humor, as the film often addresses much lighter issues than "Shoah" (as one may expect). In any case, Lanzmann's works are meant to make you think. As always, you have to be ready to absorb their content and make something out of it.

The title of the film is often incorrectly given as a question ("Why Israel?"). The documentary is rather an answer or an explanation. That is why it is still relevant to watch this documentary, even today (the film premiered in a difficult context, just when Yom Kippur war broke out in 1973), for most of the problems Israel still faces are exposed here. Lanzmann started to make extensive research for "Shoah" right after the release of "Pourquoi Israël", obviously the second part of an insightful trilogy on what is "Jewishness" today (the third part being the documentary named "Tsahal").


7 of 9 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 2 user reviews »

Contribute to This Page

Free Movies and TV Shows You Can Watch Now

On IMDb TV, you can catch Hollywood hits and popular TV series at no cost. Select any poster below to play the movie, totally free!

Browse free movies and TV series

Stream Popular Action and Adventure Titles With Prime Video

Explore popular action and adventure titles available to stream with Prime Video.

Start your free trial



Recently Viewed