Jump to:
Audio/visual unsynchronised (1) |
Character error (9) |
Continuity (4) |
Crew or equipment visible (1) |
Errors in geography (3) |
Factual errors (10) |
Miscellaneous (3) |
Incorrectly regarded as goofs (5) |
Plot holes (3) |
Revealing mistakes (12) |
Spoilers (3)
Audio/visual unsynchronised
When Mandrake finds the radio, it is on the shelf of an IBM 1403 high-speed printer, with the cover open. The printer is running; anyone who has ever been around a working 1403 printer knows that they are very loud. Operators had to shout to be heard. The printer is not making the loud noise it should be making while running in the shown 600 lines per minute mode with the cover open.
Character error
Towards the end of the film, when Strangelove is fighting with his renegade right hand over control of his wheelchair and punches it several times out of frustration, the Russian Ambassador (Peter Bull) clearly corpses (laughs) at Peter Sellers' performance and then quickly regains his composure.
De Sadesky says that the fallout from the doomsday device has a half-life of 93 years, but then he also says that the fallout would circle Earth for 93 years. This is a contradiction: half-life is the time it takes for radiation to be halved, not completely dissipated. It is common however for people to confuse these concepts, and the dissipation time for the fallout from a nuclear weapon salted with cobalt is indeed about a century.
While checking the contents of his bailout kit, Major Kong removes his Colt 1911 pistol, cycles the slide and then pulls the trigger and drops the hammer. To do this without checking to see if the pistol is unloaded is an unforgivable breach of basic rules of safe firearms handling and would never be done by anyone with military training.
De Sadesky claims that the doomsday device are large nuclear weapons that have been jacketed with a compound of Cobalt and Thorium. While Cobalt is indeed a first choice when making such a weapon, using Thorium makes no sense at all since it will not be activated by the blast to form any dangerous fallout.
When General Ripper issues the attack plan he calls it "attack plan R, R as in Robert." The correct phonetic alphabet for "R" is "Romeo." Later, on the B-52, the correct term is used.
Peter Sellers, as American President Muffley, uses the British pronunciation of the word "missile."
The B-52 radar operator, when announcing the approach of the missile, says it is closing at "Mack 3"- the British pronunciation of "Mach."
General Turgidson tries to dismiss de Sadesky's claim of the doomsday device by saying radiation from a nuclear fallout is "down to a safe level after two weeks". But the idea of creating so called "salted" nuclear weapons by using cobalt in them was put forth by Leó Szilárd - the "father of the atomic bomb" - already in February 1950, and it is this concept that doomsday device in the movie is built on. The general would be well aware of salted bombs and their capabilities in 1963 when the movie takes place.
At 20:35, whilst challenging Ripper's order, Mandrake refers to "Her Majesty's Air Force". As a senior officer [Group Captain/NATO OF-5/Equivalent to Colonel], he would have instinctively referred to the correct designation of "Royal Air Force".
Continuity
When Gen. Ripper and Capt. Mandrake are using the belt-fed machine gun, in one shot Mandrake is holding a chair over his head for protection, but when it cuts and the camera is behind them and Ripper crawls away from the window, Mandrake isn't holding the chair, and the closest chair is 10 feet away from him.
A missile explodes on the bomber, damaging many of the interior systems and switches. Yet in the exterior shots that follow of the bomber, it appears undamaged.
The long scene with Mandrake and Ripper on the floor is shot from 3 camera angles. In each view Ripper is holding the machine-gun at different heights on the barrel. Notice the two air holes visible shifting to none.
The bomber flies past the same iceberg more than once.
Crew or equipment visible
The background footage for the model B-52's is filmed from a Boeing B-17G, whose shadow can be seen on the ground. See also Trivia.
Errors in geography
Although General Turgidson says (in the War Room) that "the aircraft will begin penetrating Russian radar coverage in about 20 minutes," the map of Russia on the Big Board shows several aircraft either very close to, or in some cases actually over, the Russian border, well within the range of Soviet military radar.
General Turgidson learns from his secretary, Miss Scott, of General Ripper's ordered attack on the USSR at 3 a.m. Washington D.C. time. However, the concurrent scenes at Burpleson Air Force base (somewhere in the Western United States) take place in the daytime.
Although the War Room is supposed to be in Washington, DC (or Arlington, Virginia to be a stickler), its telephones have British GPO 700-series telephone handsets.
Factual errors
Typos in the opening captions include "Base on the book Red Alert by Peter George," "ficticious" instead of "fictitious" and "occurence" instead of "occurrence."
When General Jack D. Ripper is firing the .30 caliber machine gun with the assistance of Group Captain Lionel Mandrake, he is holding the machine gun by the barrel. In reality, this would quickly cause serious burns and would not be possible for more than a few seconds.
The hand grenades of Colonel Bat Guano's jacket are British Mills Bombs, not American hand grenades.
While on the bomb run, Major Kong orders the bomb detonator set to zero altitude. Altitudes in aviation are calculated based on sea level (which is zero altitude). As the missile base they were attacking was in the mountains, and certainly higher than zero altitude, a bomb dropped with that setting would not go off.
The depicted capabilities of the airborne radar in the B-52 are fantasy. The B-52 never had a fully rotating radar with a PPI scope, it had a ground attack radar, and the gun turret radar didn't operate like that. No airborne radar in the 1960's could detect a target as small as a surface-to-air missile at 50 miles away. A sweeping radar would not be able to display the missile exploding in mid-sweep.
The pilots wings on General Turgidson are basic pilot wings. For a four star general they should be Command Pilot Wings with a wreath and star on top.
The B-52 aircraft models shown in the film have no tail numbers.
In reality incoming missile threats are not detected by a radar on an aircraft as depicted in the movie, but by a Radar Warning Receiver. An RWR assesses threats by detecting a ground radar as it directs its tell-tale emissions at the aircraft to guide a missile to it, or by detecting a radar on-board the missile itself.
The Air Police Airmen shown are wearing their armbands on the right arm, these should be worn on the left.
The air base is shown as being overgrown with weeds. In fact, U.S. air bases are required to be maintained in appropriate condition.
Miscellaneous
George C. Scott tripped on the slippery black Formica floor, recovered and then delivered a line. The fall was an accident but it worked so it was left in.
The air base is shown as being overgrown with weeds. In fact, domestic U.S. air bases are required to be maintained in immaculate condition.
The bomber flies past the same iceberg more than once.
Incorrectly regarded as goofs
General Ripper says his entire wing of 34 B-52s are on airborne alert. Only a proportion of a wing's aircraft would be on such alert. It would not be possible to keep an entire wing on such an alert. The fact is that the General was mad and operating far beyond his brief. It was within his ability, being the aggressor, to send the entire wing if he wished.
The Coca-Cola machine squirts drink into the face of Colonel Guano after he shoots holes in it. However, there would be no reason for the bottles or cans in the machine to be under pressure, as the shooting wouldn't have shaken them up. Also, the bottles wouldn't be stored to the side of the vending door (where the bullet holes are), but above it.
The style of machine shown mixes tap water from a water line attached to the building's plumbing with carbon dioxide and drink syrup stored in tanks inside the machine under pressure and dispenses it into a paper cup that drops into a chamber in the door which is plainly visible in the shot. Therefore, it is quite plausible that water would squirt from the machine under pressure if the tanks or water lines were pierced by gunfire. This style of machine used to be quite common when this film was made in the 1960's, but are now fairly rare, as the machines had to be restocked with raw drink syrup (a different tank of syrup for each drink flavor) and recharged with carbon dioxide. Otherwise, if the syrup, carbon dioxide, or both ran out, you often received either a cup of plain soda water, a "flat" soda with no bubbles, or worst of all, a cup of plain water if both the syrup and carbon dioxide tanks were empty.
While this is correct, the whole point of this scene is comedy.
While this is correct, the whole point of this scene is comedy.
Captain Mandrake says that all he ever had to do was push the button in his Spitfire fighter, and a little later says that he was taken prisoner by the Japanese. While some might think that no spitfires were sent to eastern Asia during the war, during the final year of the war a number of Spitfire MKVIIIs did see action against the Japanese over Burma.
When the US-USSR hotline was set up in 1963, it used encrypted teletype machines, not a direct voice line. Thus, the conversation between Muffley and Kissoff would not have been possible. Naturally, for the purposes of both drama and Sellers' brilliant verbal delivery, the hot line is depicted as being a telephone.
The purpose of the doomsday machine, as stated, is to instill fear into the enemies of the USSR. But when the Russian ambassador mentions the device to the president, the president says he never heard of it.
As Dr. Strangelove himself points out, there would be no point to having a doomsday device if no one knows about it. This, of course, is one of the absurdities of nuclear deterrents that become fodder for the satire in the story.
As Dr. Strangelove himself points out, there would be no point to having a doomsday device if no one knows about it. This, of course, is one of the absurdities of nuclear deterrents that become fodder for the satire in the story.
Plot holes
In the beginning narration it is stated that western leaders were hearing rumors that the Russians were building some type of Doomsday Machine. When the Russian ambassador informs the president that they do have a Doomsday device, the president and military leaders have no idea what the ambassador is talking about.
The weight and recoil of a .50 caliber machine gun - especially when firing - is not possible for a single human to handle, or keep aimed accurately.
On the bombing run, the mile count as they approach target is separated by 19 seconds per mile, or approximately 3 miles per minute, or 180 MPH, with is considerably slower than its' low level bombing run speed of 375 MPH.
Revealing mistakes
The panel in the B-52 labeled "Auto Destruct" is in fact a flare launch control panel. Visible under the black paint are the instructions
"INSTRUCTIONS
1) PULL COVER DOWN
2) MOVE MASTER (CENTER) SWITCH DOWN
3) RELEASE A FLARE BY MOVING EITHER SIDE SWITCH"
While today's astronomical budgets can allow for all sorts of things, the fact is that the designers had to improvise virtually all of the interior. and on a limited budget. In addition, the only reference was a photo looking over a pilot's shoulder and through the windshield. The astonishing complexity of the interior was a true masterpiece for its time. In fact, when asked for their opinion, Air Force visitors on the set were stunned at how realistic it was. It was so real that Kubrick make the designer swear that none of his designs were based on classified material.
While today's astronomical budgets can allow for all sorts of things, the fact is that the designers had to improvise virtually all of the interior. and on a limited budget. In addition, the only reference was a photo looking over a pilot's shoulder and through the windshield. The astonishing complexity of the interior was a true masterpiece for its time. In fact, when asked for their opinion, Air Force visitors on the set were stunned at how realistic it was. It was so real that Kubrick make the designer swear that none of his designs were based on classified material.
When the radio operator gets the go code (FGD135) he opens the code book and pages to the "L" page, then the "J" page, then finally to the "F" page. All 3 of those pages are exactly identical, with all of the "F" go codes in fainter type. The "F" page go codes are in much darker type.
In the cockpit scenes, when the aircraft banks during evasive maneuvers, no change appears in the instruments: they continue indicating straight and level flight (notably the attitude indicator).
During the final bombing run, a few times a reflection can be seen, making visible the glass of the airplane from which the background footage was shot.
Strings can be seen holding up the model of the bomber.
According to the movie, Colonel Bat Guano is a member of the non-existent 23rd Airborne Division. As seen in the Coca-Cola machine scene, his shoulder patch is from the 2nd Infantry Division.
During the firefight between General Ripper and the Army soldiers, the office windows are blown out. But the outside camera shots of the office building shows the windows are intact.
Several back projection shots of Maj. Kong's B-52 make it appear as though the plane is flying much faster than the highest possible air speed for a B-52.
Wing attack Plan R, as read by Major Kong, includes an ICBM complex, to receive a 30-megaton bomb, airburst at 10,000 feet. In reality, such a target, being hardened (probably underground), would call for a ground burst.
Several times during the film, when the B52 is shown in flight from the side, even though the camera angle "pans" with the aircraft when banking (turning), there is no change in the angle or geography of the scenery on the background plate footage - it still looks as if the plane were in straight level flight.
The first time we see the War Room, there's a binder in front of General Turgidson where the spine reads "World Targets in Megadeath". Its position changes during the long scene, and at one point we can view the contents, and the binder is empty.
At about 1.50 into the film, the B52 is hit by a missile. The B52 has been taking evasive action for some time beforehand. When the two airmen jump out of their seats, you see a paper coffee cup and a plate on their work space, undisturbed by the maneuvering or the missile strike.
Spoilers
Continuity
While Major Kong is trying to get the bomb bay doors open, the B-52 is shown flying just above the treeline, but when the doors open and the bomb drops, the plane is clearly thousands of feet up.
The fact is that the bomb bay doors were not supposed to function. At the last moment Kubrick decided to shoo the scene with open doors in the background but they had not planned ahead and had no background footage from that angle.
The fact is that the bomb bay doors were not supposed to function. At the last moment Kubrick decided to shoo the scene with open doors in the background but they had not planned ahead and had no background footage from that angle.
Incorrectly regarded as goofs
When Mandrake made the phone call to the president, the communication system was supposed to be dead. However, there are no doubt multiple phone lines going into a major air base, and it is quite conceivable that a public pay phone would be on a completely separate phone system than the direct line to SAC Headquarters. In fact, Mandrake did mention the possibility that it would not be working.
Revealing mistakes
After having shot the Coca-Cola machine, Colonel Bat Guano leans down to grab the coins and is subsequently hit in the face with a stream of the soft drink. Keenan Wynn's head was too high when the stream began to spew toward him, and he can be seen lowering his face down into it to produce the full comedic effect.
