5.8/10
168
9 user 2 critic

Lorna Doone (1951)

TV-PG | | Adventure, Drama, Romance | 31 May 1951 (USA)
Set in 17th century Scotland, a young woman falls in love with a humble villager whose community suffers under the rule of her despotic landowning family.

Director:

Phil Karlson

Writers:

R.D. Blackmore (novel) (as Richard D. Blackmore), George Bruce (adaptation) | 2 more credits »
Reviews

Photos

Edit

Cast

Cast overview:
Barbara Hale ... Lorna Doone
Richard Greene ... John Ridd
Carl Benton Reid ... Sir Ensor Doone
William Bishop ... Carver Doone
Ron Randell ... Tom Faggus
Sean McClory ... Charleworth Doone
Onslow Stevens ... Counsellor Doone
Lester Matthews ... King Charles II
John Dehner ... Baron de Wichehalse
Gloria Petroff Gloria Petroff ... Lorna Doone as a Child
Edit

Storyline

Set in 17th century Scotland, a young woman falls in love with a humble villager whose community suffers under the rule of her despotic landowning family.

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis


Certificate:

TV-PG | See all certifications »
Edit

Did You Know?

Goofs

John and Tom accompany the sheriff to the gate of Doone Castle and once through the sheriff shouts a warning to the guards who are killed along with the sheriff but at one point in the background is a man in a plumed hat. but has appeared out of nowhere. See more »

Connections

Version of Lorna Doone (1915) See more »

User Reviews

 
LORNA DOONE (Phil Karlson, 1951) **1/2
2 April 2014 | by Bunuel1976See all my reviews

This Hollywood rendition of the British literary classic by R.D. Blackmore was dubbed "grotesque" by the late, eminent but notoriously conservative film critic Leslie Halliwell where, he opined, the narrative was treated "as if it were a Western"! Such a damning assessment did not augur well, to be sure – but, then, Leonard Maltin rated it higher than the director's best-regarded costumer i.e. the just-watched THE BRIGAND (1952). The truth, as often happens, lies somewhere in between: while the plot does feel like a typical 'terrorized homestead' scenario, it is nevertheless engaging (indeed, more so than the better-received 1934 version that had preceded this viewing!) and, to its credit, looks veritably gorgeous in the Technicolor print shown on Australian HD-TV I acquired (despite the "Back Soon" and "Now" announcements signalling frequent commercial breaks!). Still, it does not quite have the impetus to rise above the clichés – lacking the wit and verve that would characterize THE BRIGAND and substituting glumness, ill-matched stars (Barbara Hale and Richard Greene) and a decidedly anodyne villain (William Bishop)!

While the essence of the tale, at least as shown in the earlier adaptation, is there, a number of crucial differences are also on hand – which, again, can either work in its favour or against: first of all, the Doones (headed by siblings Carl Benton Reid and Onslow Stevens) reside in a castle and, rather than mere bandits, are overlords enslaving the people a' la Prince John in the Robin Hood legends; the male protagonist here is a soldier in King Charles II (not James!)'s army, so that the opposition he offers involves military tactics (a planned sneak attack by way of the waterfall which had introduced the hero to Lorna as kids) instead of just an impulsive personal vendetta; the character of Tom Faggus (played this time around by Ron Randell) is much more important here but, then, his romance with Greene's barely- registering sister feels contrived; a number of violent scenes (floggings, hangings) are incorporated, culminating in full-blown swashbuckling action at the climax; there is not one but two interrupted wedding ceremonies (in both of which Lorna is the prospective bride!), with the last semi-tragic one preceding the inevitable showdown between her two contenders – which, however, ends with the predictable fall from a great height and not a marshland drowning; Lorna's background (a spiteful kidnapping stunting her regal birthright), on the other hand, is more than adequately dealt with…since the King himself comes into play on a couple of occasions! With this, I am now left with the Silent 1922 filmization by Maurice Tourneur to check out – while marking the start of a three-movie mini-marathon dedicated to Greene as part of my current Epic Easter viewings.


9 of 12 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 9 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
Edit

Details

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Release Date:

31 May 1951 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

Burg der Rache See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Runtime:

Sound Mix:

Mono (Western Electric Recording)

Color:

Color (Technicolor)

Aspect Ratio:

1.37 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page



Recently Viewed