The Fighting Frontiersman (1946) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Swamp Woman Blues
krorie3 September 2006
This rather routine Durango Kid outing is enlivened by several good musical numbers, three written and performed by Smiley Burnette, a much better musician and songwriter than comedian, and one written by Bob Newman of the western swing group, The Georgia Crackers, not up to the standards of Bob Wills and his Texas Playboys but still well above average. There is also a fine rendition of Stephen Foster's "Old Folks at Home (Swanee River)," given a western twist by the band.

Of Smiley's three songs, "Don't Be Mad At Me," "Swamp Woman Blues," and "Coyote Song," "Swamp Woman Blues" is the most innovative. It's only 1946 and already Smiley is helping lead the way toward hillbilly boogie that would later be perfected by the likes of the Delmore Brothers featuring the virtuoso harmonica player from the hills of Arkansas, Wayne Rainey. Smiley's mouth harp has a blues feeling to it seldom heard by white players of the day. It's good that Smiley's music is so invigorating for his attempt at humor in "The Fighting Frontiersman" is lame.

The story by pulp fiction writer Ed Earl Repp concerns the discovery of Santa Anna's treasure by prospector Cimmaron Dobbs played by funny man Emmett Lynn, with two mules (Elmer and Amarillie)that often get more laughs than Lynn. Supposedly Mexican President/Generalisimo Santa Anna hid the treasure after the war to keep it out of the hands of the Texicans but the script doesn't make it exactly clear which war, the War for Texas Independence or the Mexican War. The beginning of the film indicates that it may have been the Civil War, but that would be historically incorrect.

Cimmaron was grub staked by his old pals in the saddle, Steve Reynolds (Charles Starrett) and Smiley Burnette (Smiley Burnette). Cimmaron has a better looking pal at the local saloon, a songbird named Dixie (Helen Mowery). It's not completely clear just whose side Dixie is on. Not long after Cimmaron's conversation with Dixie about his recent discovery, explaining to her that he was sending for Steve and Smiley to assist and protect him, that John Munro (Robert Filmer) and his three henchman, one being the famous stuntman Jock Mahoney as Waco, kidnap the old timer, hide him out, then try to torture him into telling them where the loot is hid. Steve's alter ego, The Durango Kid, is determined to free Cimmaron and share the wealth with the town folks.

Though there is plenty of action that makes one think of a Republic feature, much stock footage is used, giving the avid Durango Kid fan a feeling of déjà vu. Some of the editing of the old with the new is so amateurish that at times the old film and the new film are out of sync.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Semi-Musical
boblipton26 October 2014
This is a typically lively early Durango Kid western -- star Starrett had been making movies since 1930s and had moved into B westerns half a dozen years later -- with some good songs by Smiley Burnette and Western Swing group, the Georgia Crackers. Cinematographer Philip Tanura's work is unremarkable, although his interior shots are very formal.

The story is centered around people looking for and fighting over Santa Ana's gold, which is just as good a starting point as any for a B western Western, since it all come down to an arrangement of the tropes of westerns. There is a nice, confusing series of double-crosses to keep the viewer interested. There is an early series example of using a narrator to set the story. With a screen time of 61 minutes, it helps to get through at such a speed, although later Durango Kids would wind up using it as a crutch as budgets tightened.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Santa Ana's gold causes some excitement.
michaelRokeefe9 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Charles Starrett vehicle directed by Derwin Abrahams; the Ed Earl Repp screenplay is pretty predictable. A grizzled old-timer named Cimarron Dobbs(Emmett Lynn)accidentally finds a large horde of Spanish gold left behind by Santa Ana's army. He feels he needs some help keeping someone else from getting their hands on it and saloon girl Dixie(Helen Mowery)wants to help him. she mails pal Steve Reynolds(Starrett)and he arrives with saddle buddy Smiley Burnette. When the old prospector is kidnapped it seems saloon owner John Munro(Robert Filmer)and his gang are connected to it. Reynolds dons his Durango Kid outfit and goes into hero mode. For a bit of comedy, Smiley banters about with a lady barber(Maudie Prickett). And of course there are some hillbilly songs to stretch the movie out. The better tunes being: "The Old Folks At Home" by Lynn, "Follow The Trail" by Hank Newman and Burnette's funny "Swamp Woman Blues".

Nothing unexpected or out of the norm. A decent cowboy flick that also stars: George Chesebro, Zon Murray, Jim Diehl and Frank Ellis.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Who Was That Masked Man?
bsmith555215 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"The Fighting Frontiersman" is another of Columbia's long running Durango Kid series starring Charles Starrett and Smiley Burnette. Of particular interest in this one is the fact that the leading heavy actually unmasks Durango but doesn't survive to tell anyone of his discovery.

An old sourdough miner, Cimarron Dobbs (Emmett Lynn) stumbles onto a hidden cache of gold left by the infamous Santa Ana's army in an isolated cave. Cimarron confides in saloon girl Dixie King (Helen Mowery) of his find only to have bad guy Rankin (George Chesebro) over hear. Rankin informs his boss John Munro (Robert Fibner) who quickly arranges for Cimarron to be kidnapped and taken away to a secret hideout.

Dixie writes to Ranger Steve Reynolds (Starrett) informing him of the kidnapping. Steve and Smiley arrive on the scene and immediately suspect Munro and his cronies. The Durango Kid appears and makes the gang uneasy as they attempt to get Cimarron to reveal the hiding place of the gold. Durango offers a reward of $5,000 to boot.

Munro enlists the aid of Dixie (but can she be trusted?) to get Cimarron to give up the gold. Steve leads a posse towards the hideout. A confrontation ensues, Durango appears at the hideout and.........................................................

It's interesting to note that Jock Mahoney who doubled Starrett in action scenes actually has the part of henchman Waco in the film. If I'm not mistaken he actually winds up chasing himself in the chase sequences involving Durango.

Hank Newman and the Georgia Crackers provide the musical entertainment along with Burnette who sings a couple of tunes with them. Smiley also gets tangled up with lady barber Kate (Maudie Prickett). Also watch for veterans Zon Murray as henchman Slade and Ernie Adams as the printer.

You know, I always wondered how the Steve character could so easily change into Durango and back so fast especially since there were no phone booths around in those days.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The fighting frontiersman
coltras3527 February 2022
Prospector Cimarron Dobbs (Emmett Lynn) stumbles on a vast cache of Spanish gold left in Texas by Santa Anna's army, and knows he will be swindled out of his discovery unless he gets help. Saloon hostess Dixie King (Helen Mowery) agrees that he must secure the help of the Durango Kid (Charles Starrett), otherwise known as Steve Reynolds. Dobbs is kidnapped by a gang headed by John Munro (Robert Filmer'), owner of the saloon where Dixie works.

Another serviceable entry which has some good twist and turns, especially in the character Dixie whose motives of trying to help Dobb escape from the hideout where he's kept prisoner. Is she after the treasure herself? Another plus point is George Chesbro who is a clever villain; he schemes things well. The finale is a cliffhanger.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quite a novel story development!
JohnHowardReid29 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Charles Starrett (Steve Reynolds/The Durango Kid), Smiley Burnette (himself), Helen Mowery (Dixie King), Emmett Lynn (Cimarron Dobbs), Frank LaRue (Roberts, the banker), George Chesebro (Rankin), Jock Mahoney (Waco), Ernie Adams (printer), Maudie Prickett (barber), Zon Murray (Slade), Jim Diehl (Blaze), Frank Ellis (Frank), Herman Hack (henchman), Robert Filmer (John Munro), Russell Meeker (bartender), Blackie Whiteford, George Plues, Ray Jones (barflies), Kit Guard, Victor Cox, Foxy Callahan, Jack Evans (townsmen), Hank Newman and the Georgia Crackers (themselves).

Director: DERWIN ABRAHAMS. Original screenplay: Ed Earl Repp. Photography: Philip Tannura. Film editor: Jerome Thoms. Art director: Charles Clague. Set decorator: Robert Bradfield. Music director: Mischa Bakaleinikoff. Stunt double for Charles Starrett: Jock Mahoney. Production manager: Jack Fier. Assistant director: Carter De Haven, Jr. Sound recording: Lambert Day. Producer: Colbert Clark.

Copyright 19 December 1946 by Columbia Pictures Corporation. No recorded New York opening. U.S. release: 10 December 1946. Australian release: 28 August 1947. 6 reels. 5,578 feet. 61 minutes.

U.K. release title: GOLDEN LADY.

SYNOPSIS: Prospector discovers a cache of gold in the Texas hills.

NOTES: Starrett's 85th western.

COMMENT: This Durango Kid entry is worth seeing if only the invigorating presence of Helen Mowery who adds more than a spice of interest to an already promising script idea. (We are never quite sure whose side she's on, which—by the standards of the "B" western which tends to relegate heroines to the decorative sidelines—is quite a novel story development).

The other players are also more than merely competent. And it's always a pleasure to catch George Chesebro at his villainous best.

Derwin Abrahams has directed with unusual (for him) pace and drive. Even the musical interludes are also pleasant.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed