Complete credited cast: | |||
James Stewart | ... | Gaylord Esterbrook | |
Rosalind Russell | ... | Linda Paige Esterbrook | |
Genevieve Tobin | ... | Amanda Swift | |
Charles Ruggles | ... | Philo Swift (as Charlie Ruggles) | |
Allyn Joslyn | ... | Morgan Carrell | |
Clarence Kolb | ... | Richard Benson | |
Louise Beavers | ... | Clementine | |
J.M. Kerrigan | ... | Jim | |
![]() |
Lawrence Grossmith | ... | Frank (as Lawrence Grosmith) |
Robert Greig | ... | Robert | |
Frank Faylen | ... | Cab Driver | |
Rest of cast listed alphabetically: | |||
![]() |
Bonnie Gaye Cowen |
Playwright Gaylord Esterbrook scores a hit with his first Broadway play, both with the critics and with leading lady Linda Paige. He and Linda are happily married until a patroness of the arts convinces Esterbrook to forget about comedy and concentrate on writing a tragedy. The end result nearly destroys his career and his marriage. Written by Daniel Bubbeo <dbubbeo@cmp.com>
Successful comic playwright Jimmy Stewart decides that the times he is living in call for political drama instead of laughs. His stage star wife disagrees and must win him back from the clutches of the pretentious matron who has him in her thrall. Though one would think that the tall, lanky duo of Stewart and Rosalind Russell would be perfect together, they disappoint. They manage some charm and chemistry in the early parts of the film, but both surrender to stridency later on, and this movie has none of the fast pace or glossy sheen a sophisticated comedy set in Manhattan should have.
What is interesting here is the cultural mirror of the times. The amusing portrait of a cynical Manhattan is still recognizable, and the thesis that in bad times there is nothing more important than making people laugh is the same one Preston Sturges explored in his overrated SULLIVAN'S TRAVELS a year or so later. Though this film doesn't mix comedy and message drama as well as Sturges did, however imperfectly, the penultimate scene here is intriguing. Russell is prepared to marry the droll plutocrat whose wife has stolen Stewart from her, but he lets loose with a string of invective that probably accurately reflected the 'America First' Republicanism of the time. Russell decides that she'd rather be with a man who hates the fact that the free world was being taken over by fascists than by a man who sees all dictators with cynical detachment.
This film is heavy and crude where it should be light, and the implied sexual sophistication of the plot is not directed or played with the right tone at all. But this misfire will still manage to be of interest to some.