Billy the Kid Returns (1938) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"You need a new Billy The Kid, 'aincha?"
classicsoncall20 April 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Western film fans will recognize the characters and locale of "Billy The Kid Returns", though not the spin off tale that forms the basis of this story. Roy Rogers performs double duty as both the legendary badman and his good guy counterpart, a character sharing Rogers' own name. When Billy is gunned down by Sheriff Pat Garrett, ensuing scenes depict Roy Rogers and pal Trigger riding into Lincoln County, New Mexico. Those who know Billy give a wide berth to Rogers, respecting the reputation of a gunman who had twenty one kills to his credit by the young age of twenty.

I'd never seen it before, but here it was more than obvious. In the shootout scene at the opening, whenever Roy as Billy fired his guns he would close his eyes. This happened four times during the confrontation, and once more when a man challenged Billy for stealing his horse. Perhaps it was a convention used for this particular movie, and wasn't noticed when Rogers became the character Rogers in the rest of the film.

The movie offers more than the usual share of musical numbers for a Roy Rogers effort. Roy himself performs four songs, and with the first, it looks like Trigger is keeping time with 'Born in the Saddle'. Beyond that, Smiley Burnette and his boys turn in three additional tunes to keep things merry. In the story, Burnette's character is Frog Millhouse, utilizing that throaty voice every once in a while during his songs. I find it interesting that the fictional character Frog Millhouse played by Smiley was also used in movies starring other cowboy performers, primarily Gene Autry, but at least once with Sunset Carson in "Call of the Rockies".

Roy Rogers' late 1930's movies usually found Lynne Roberts as the female lead, her character here is Ellen Moore, daughter of a general store owner. You'll see her listed in the film credits as Mary Hart, and she worked with Roy in eight films.

The story itself has a plot used time and again throughout Western movie history, the conflict between homesteaders and range land cattle men. Rogers teams with Pat Garrett (Wade Boteler) to thwart a band of villain ranchers who intimidate homesteaders by stealing their horses and provoking general mayhem. The good guys prevail of course, as Roy and Miss Ellen close the film in a smooch with Smiley literally falling off the wagon.

Roy Rogers wound up portraying a number of historical men of the West in his movies. If you liked this film, you might want to catch him as "Young Bill Hickok", "Jesse James at Bay", and "Young Buffalo Bill", all from 1940/41.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quite enjoyable.
planktonrules5 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of Roy Rogers' first starring films and one of the earliest where he's billed using this moniker. He'd appeared in a few films in small roles as Leonard Slye (his real name) as well as in a couple as 'Dick Weston'. Because of his age, he's extremely handsome and photogenic--and it's pretty obvious to see why he's now got starring roles.

I was concerned when I began watching this film. That's because I am a history teacher and hate how obscure western characters like Jesse James, The Sundance Kid and Billy the Kid have been turned into heroes--heroes that have NOTHING to do with the actual criminals they purport to be. The last thing I wanted to see was a film that made Billy look like a nice guy--and the film does NOT do that--though, as history records, he was a man who had friends among the homesteaders. It begins with the Kid in a shootout and he viciously kills a guy at close range--and this actor doing this IS Roy Rogers! Roy cannot be a murderer--it's just totally against his upright image. BUT, here is how they do it. After you see the real Billy killed by lawman Pat Garrett, Roy Rogers (playing a character named Roy Rogers!) shows up in the territory and people think he is the Kid. But he's clearly the good guy, Roy.

The people of the territory, however, don't know yet that Billy is dead and a posse captures Roy--thinking he's the outlaw. Garrett, however, comes to his rescue. Now the Sheriff and Garrett both concoct a plan where Roy will pose as Billy. First, they have to have the ersatz Billy 'escape' from jail. Then, Roy will do the good things the Kid once did--protecting the little ranchers from the corrupt bosses trying to push them around for kicks. And, hopefully, they can get some evidence of the bosses violating a federal law--since Garrett is a Marshall and has the authority to arrest them should they break any of these laws.

All in all, one of the more enjoyable Rogers films. I've seen. While I am far from an expert on his films, it was nice having Smiley along for the ride--he had a nice voice and offered some good comic relief. And, the story, which is a bit silly if you think about it, at least does NOT promote the silly wild west images of the anti-hero. Well worth seeing.

By the way, Roy's sidekick, Smiley Burnett, was a frequent sidekick for Gene Autry. Later in life, he was known on TV as one of the conductors of the train on "Petticoat Junction" and "Green Acres". Oddly, of the two who ran the train, Smiley was distinguishable because he smiled a lot less than his partner (Rufe Davis)! And, ironically, the guy who replaced him in the Autry series was Pat Butram--the same guy who played Mr. Haney on the same two TV shows!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Typical But Enjoyable Roy Rodgers Vehicle
FightingWesterner11 February 2010
Sheriff Pat Garrett corners and kills Billy the kid. The next day, lookalike Roy Rodgers rides into town and is immediately mistaken for the outlaw, who's death has yet to be reported. Roy's then pressed into service by Garrett, who wants him to take the place of Billy in a range war pitting ruthless ranchers against the homesteaders that the late kid had intervened on behalf of.

This second starring vehicle for Rodgers is decent enough, with lots of great songs from Roy and sidekick Smiley Burnette. He still hadn't quite gotten the hang of the acting profession, with a less sure Rodgers delivering his lines in a slightly different tone of voice!

This was the first of three times that Roy played a dual role in his films, the second being 1941's Jesse James At Bay and the third being 1942's Sunset On The Desert.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Entertaining Spin on History
Michael_Elliott19 April 2012
Billy the Kid Returns (1938)

*** (out of 4)

Pat Garrett kills Billy the Kid (Roy Rogers) but in another town a lookalike named Roy Rogers shows up and is mistaken as the real person. Rogers agrees to pretend to be Billy the Kid so that he can uncover a group of bad guys trying to steal land from the poor. This here was one of Rogers earliest films and as many reviewers pointed out at the time, there's really no question that crowds would enjoy his brand of singing and acting and it was clear that his personality jumped right off the screen and he was perfect for this type of character. He has to play pretty much two different roles here and I thought Rogers did a very good job with each of them. This includes playing a bad guy with no heart in Billy and the good guy who cares about those around him. Smiley Burnette gets the role of the sidekick and he too is charming in the film and adds some nice humor. Lynne Roberts plays the love interest and nearly steals each scene that she's in. She's plays the hard-working daughter of a hard-working store owner who just knows that Rogers isn't a bad guy. She's quite attractive to look at but she also gives a performance that comes across quite soft and charming. There's plenty of action to be had here and the majority of the gunfights are good, well-staged and entertaining. I'd also say that the cinematography is much better than you'd expect from this type of low-budget Western. Just check out the early scenes inside the house that is on fire. There's a shot of Billy the Kid firing guns with the fire and smoke behind him and it's a very good looking shot. Fans of Rogers will certainly find this to be one of his better films even if it's certainly not worth viewing as any type of history lesson on the real Billy the Kid.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
typical western from Replublic... R Rogers
ksf-226 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILERS ** Kind of a convoluted plot, but when Billy the Kid is killed off, Roy Rogers steps in as Kid to help the cause of the homesteaders. It's a real shortie from Republic Pictures, at only 53 minutes. Roy Rogers and Trigger are the big names in this one. Lester Smiley Burnette, part time musician and inventor, is here as the sidekick "Frog". Lots of backdrops and close-ups. Sound quality is pretty terrible.It's a bit hokey... WHO would ever pretend to be a wanted, known murderer?? .. and good thing he can play guitar and sing! The film opens with the real Billy getting knocked off, and here comes Roy stepping in for him, minus the murdering. Some scenes filmed at "Corriganville", in north LA, now a county park, worth visiting if you're in the area. Corriganville is very interesting, historically. so many films made there. The film is okay...nothing new or special, but it IS Roy Rogers and Trigger. maybe it will be restored at some point. Showing on Film Detective Channel. Directed by Joe Kane, the expert in Westerns. After his career as a cellist, of course. Acc to wikipedia, he was already about 40 when he got into pictures. Written by Jack Natteford, who had written TONS of stuff, starting in silent films.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
His Robin Hood ways
bkoganbing12 June 2013
For Roy Rogers second starring feature Republic Pictures had him play Billy The Kid in Billy The Kid Returns. He also plays a nice chap named Roy Rogers who wants to become a deputy sheriff to Pat Garrett.

When the film opens we see Roy as Billy breaking out of that famous shootout at McSween's store and later shot down by Pat Garrett played here by Wade Boteler. But Roy as Roy arrives from Texas and is mistaken for the notorious outlaw. As he's a good guy Garrett keeps up the deception as Billy continues his Robin Hood ways of helping the homesteaders and robbing the cattle barons to do it All this is winked at by Boteler because he's under pressure to protect the new settlers.

In the end through the aid of Smiley Burnette on loan from Gene Autry films and playing his Frog Millhouse character Garrett and Rogers find a way to get the cattlemen good and nailed for their crimes. In the meantime Roy finds a bit of romance with Lynne Roberts the storekeeper's daughter. Roberts would be Roy's leading lady in most of his early films.

A couple of nice western ballads are included for Roy in this second film which proved that his success in Under Western Stars was not a flash in the pan.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
No action climax!
JohnHowardReid20 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Copyright 4 September 1938 by Republic Pictures Corp. No recorded New York release date. U.S. release date: 4 September 1938. U.K. release through British Lion. Never theatrically released in Australia. 6 reels. 54 minutes. SYNOPSIS: A lawman impersonates Billy the Kid in order to stop a rancher hassling nesters.

NOTES: Rogers' 14th film and second starring vehicle. Mary Hart is sometimes billed under her real name, Lynne Roberts.

COMMENT: A singing Billy the Kid? Well no, it's actually Leonard Slye's Roy Rogers impersonating Billy the Kid - though he does play in a straight fashion Billy himself as well. The two characters never appear on screen together as the real Billy is shot before the Rogers character appears on the scene.

Aside from this unusual intro, it's a likable enough if thoroughly routine offering. Fred Kohler does the honors as the villain's chief henchman, the heroine is pretty, Mr Rogers does a bit of fast riding culminating in a spectacular horse-and-rider leap from cliff-top into a lake, whilst Mr Burnette's foolery and novelty numbers are fairly tolerable.

A couple of Mr Rogers' songs are melodic enough to deserve more than the somewhat perfunctory treatment they're given here. Not that this will worry the fans. What will disappoint the juvenile audience is that there's no action climax. The villains are captured by a ruse and quietly, hang-doggedly submit. Direction and other credits are competent but thoroughly routine. Production values are firmly "B".
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Okay Roy Rogers film would have been better had it not looked like every other Republic Western
dbborroughs19 May 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Bad guy Billy the kid is cornered and killed by Pat Garret. Not long after singing cowboy Roy Rogers shows up and is mistaken for the dead villain. He has to prove himself as a lawman in order to convince people that he's not the deceased bad guy. Okay Republic Pictures programmer is well made and has a certain flair for the dramatic. The problem is that its is one of a series of films where Rogers essentially plays himself, granted in period, so any sense that anything can happen is lost. Rogers was a stalwart hero and its easy to understand why he became a star with him shining in a variation of a plot he'd done before and run into again. The problem is that like much of the Republic production at the time, the film is too by the numbers. There was a point when Republic became so good at what they did that there films became essentially off the shelf machine with the various parts switched in and out in an off the shelf formulaic manner. The serials and many of the westerns they cranked out all looked the same because they just switched parts that worked around. This doesn't mean its bad, its not its just that the film looks and acts like the rest of the republic western product. Worth a look if you've not seen a great number of republic westerns recently.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Everybody knows that you can lie faster than a dog can lick a plate."
mark.waltz19 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Now that's a line Shakespeare wishes that he wrote. In this low budget western, Roy Rogers plays a man by the name of Roy Rogers who is mistaken for the supposedly deceased Billy the Kid. It's the day after Pat Garrett (Wade Boteler) he claims that he killed Billy, so they utilize Roy Rogers in an effort to trap the rest of his gang by putting out a notice that he's taking Billy back to put him on trial. Boteler, showing regret over having to kill someone that he mentored before he went astray, comes to look at Roy as Billy's replacement, having initially wanted Billy to help him keep law and prevent land raiders from stealing others property. Smiley Burnette and Mary Hart co-star as the sidekick in the lady love, with Hart obviously having once been in love with the real Billy.

It was obvious in his first film as a lead that Roy Rogers had something special and that stardom was guaranteed the moment he began singing and riding the range as its newest hero. Hart is quite pretty, and has a lot more to do than just your typical romantic Western heroine. She really is a part of the story other than the romantic aspect of it. There's plenty of music and comedy and action, and that makes sense a notch above the typical B Western, of which there were hundreds of a year.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Cut to pieces
vincentlynch-moonoi9 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
As far as I am aware, all the Roy Rogers movies ran around 70 minutes. This one is down to 53 minutes because the idiots cut sections of the film out to later fit into an hour long t.v. Time slot...with commercials. The idiots didn't keep clean copies of most of Roy's films. The cut here is rather apparent, and toward the end of the film where a change in the plot seems to drop out of nowhere, leading to the climax. As a result it's difficult to rate most of these films.

This is not the most brilliant plot to begin with. Billy The Kid -- a sort of hero to some -- is killed by Sheriff Pat Garrett. Okay. Then along comes Roy Roger, who just happens to look exactly like Billy The Kid. And Garrett hires Roy to pretend he's Billy to get the ranchers who are harassing the settlers. Dumb. But actually pleasantly done.

Roy was a handsome young man here. So innocent looking, and a number of his songs here are left intact. Smiley Burnette is a poor substitute for Gabby Hayes, but he's okay. No one else stands out here.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Rogers On The Rise
boblipton15 July 2023
Roy Rogers tells boyhood friend and drummer in musical instruments -- he sells them -- Smiley Burnett that he is looking for a job as a peace officer. He was one back home, but a new sheriff came in and thought he looked too young. He's seized by the ranchers and taken to Marshall Joseph Crehan as Billy the Kid, but Pat Garrett (played by Wade Boteler) says he isn't; he shot and killed Billy just last night. That's too bad. Billy has been the only effective protection that homesteaders have had against the cattlemen. So they cook up a scheme, where they pretend Roy is Billy, escapes, and continues to protect the farmers. Plus new storekeeper Edwin Stanley and his pretty daughter Lynne Roberts.

Republic must have seen what a gold mine they had in Rogers, whose previous movie bit was yodeling in a cartoon. Director Joseph Kane pounded Jack Natteford's script into shape, gave Rogers a chance to do some acting in a brief prequel as Billy the Kid, set the musical intervals well, gave him a spectacular stunt or two (it looks like Trigger carrying Rogers jumps off a 100-foot cliff into the river), and the excellent print makes Ernest Miller's camerawork look fine. Then they gave it a world premiere at the L. A. Orpheum with Rogers in a personal appearance.

At first, Rogers had been insurance against Gene Autry; all the majors hired back-up performers to keep their stars' demands under control. Now, however, he was clearly being seen as a star on his own, and was getting good scripts, good casts, and good crews. It would pay off handsomely for everyone.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very early Roy Rogers movie, he plays two roles.
TxMike5 September 2022
I was a boy back in the 1950s and went into town often to watch Roy Rogers movies. I found a DVD at my public library with five old, B&W Roy Rogers movies, this is the second one I watched, running under an hour.

The hook here is that Roy Rogers is a spitting image of Billy the Kid. Roy is riding west to try to find some work, the first place he stops he is mistaken for the outlaw. He is brought in, everyone thinks he is the outlaw, until he plays the guitar and sings a song. Then everyone says "We know for a fact that Billy the Kid can't sing or play music." So Roy manages to get a temporary assignment helping Sheriff Pat Garrett.

The story here is settlers from out East are having a hard time because of the cattle ranchers' meddling. They have to plow their land but the horses get stolen. Charging them locally wouldn't do any good, their friends on a jury would just acquit them. So Rogers and Garrett hatch a plan to have the US Cavalry catch the men with stolen US horses, that would require them to be in a federal trial.

As with most (or all) Roy Rogers movies he does some singing and he of course had a great, melodic baritone voice, as good a singer as any in those days. And he did find a girl to get sweet on him.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Look-Alike
StrictlyConfidential11 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
"Billy The Kid Returns" was originally released back in 1938.

Anyway - As the story goes - Roy Rogers plays a dual role in this western portraying Billy the Kid and also himself, who is identical in appearance to Billy. After Billy the Kid is gunned down by Pat Garrett, Rogers appears in town and causes some confusion due to his likeness to the outlaw. After a series of misunderstandings due to the mistaken identity, Rogers is able to redeem himself by bringing some criminals to justice.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed