6.7/10
266
11 user 7 critic

A Modern Musketeer (1917)

A restless young man travels west, encountering adventure, romance, and danger.

Director:

Allan Dwan

Writers:

Allan Dwan (photoplay), E.P. Lyle Jr. (based upon "D'Artagnan of Kansas" by)
Reviews

Photos

Edit

Cast

Complete credited cast:
Douglas Fairbanks ... Ned Thacker / D'Artagnan
Marjorie Daw ... Elsie Dodge
Kathleen Kirkham ... Mrs. Dodge
Eugene Ormonde Eugene Ormonde ... Forrest Vandeteer
Edythe Chapman ... Mrs. Thacker
Frank Campeau ... Chin-de-dah
Tully Marshall ... James Brown
Edit

Storyline

Ned Thacker, through prenatal suggestion, is born in Kansas with the spirit of D'Artagnan, of Gascony, and, naturally, his gallantries are very much misunderstood by maids and matrons of today, but when he falls in love with Dorothy Morane it takes something more than a millionaire rival to head him off, and it takes even more than a half-crazed Indian guide and the face of the Grand Canyon to keep him from the lady of his choice; not even her mother can do that. Written by Moving Picture World synopsis

Plot Summary | Plot Synopsis

Taglines:

In This New Play Fairbanks Performs Amazing Feats


Certificate:

Passed | See all certifications »
Edit

Did You Know?

Trivia

Marjorie Daw and Kathleen Kirkham, daughter and mother, were seven years apart in age. Daw was only 15(!) when this film was made, which means that she was closer in age to the actress playing her mother than she was to the actor playing her leading man (Douglas Fairbanks was 18 years her senior). See more »

Goofs

When Chin-de-dah leads Vandeteer and Elsie through the Canyon, the shadows of the cameraman and another crew member are visible on the ground. See more »

Crazy Credits

Except for Douglas Fairbanks, whose name appears above the title, there is no cast list. Actors are introduced by intertitle cards just before they appear on the screen. The IMDb cast list therefore uses this "order of appearance" sequence. See more »

Alternate Versions

In 2006, the Danish Film Institute copyrighted a 68-minute version of this film, with a musical score played by the Mont Alto Orchestra. Additional restoration and music credits stretch the time to 69 minutes. See more »

Connections

Referenced in Chaplin (1992) See more »

User Reviews

 
A Chivalrous Man
4 May 2012 | by sddavis63See all my reviews

This will be one of the more enjoyable silent movies you'll come across - restored by the Danish Film Institute and of very good quality, and starring one of the greats of the silent era - Douglas Fairbanks, Sr. - as Ned Thacker, a man raised in Kansas being read the stories of D'Artagnan by his mother, and who grows up to be a modern day version of the musketeer, defending the honour of women at every step.

The movie opens with two really good fight scenes - a swashbuckling look back at D'Artagnan (also played by Fairbanks) as he fights to re-claim a woman's handkerchief, and our first look at Thatcher in a bar-room brawl as he defends the honour of a woman he thought was being treated poorly by her male companion. These were both fun scenes, and I enjoyed the unexpected humour as we got a glimpse of how Ned started his career as a chivalrous man by being arrested on a streetcar as he demands that a man give up his seat for two women, only to discover that the man was the chief of police! So the story had a good start.

If it lost its way a bit, it was in the decision to then focus exclusively on Ned's pursuit of Elsie Dodge (Marjorie Daw) - a young woman being forced by her mother into a relationship with a rich man in order to help pay bills. I thought the story might have been more effective if it had continued to be a series of vignettes of Thacker defending women in various circumstances. The move into the Grand Canyon, and the introduction of the bad Indian Chin-de-dah (Frank Campeau) - who fancies himself a king and decides he's going to kidnap and marry Elsie - struck me as an unnecessary diversion, which ended up as far more than a diversion - it becomes the story.

Still, if that goes a little too far, this was still a fun movie. There's no doubt about that. I enjoyed Fairbanks. Overall I thought both the movie and Fairbanks had the feel of something you might have seen remade by Bob Hope in the 1940's - a light, silly, Western-oriented comedy. A typical line, for example, that I could easily have seen put on Hope's mouth (which, of course, in this is simply a caption) comes as Ned and Elsie look at the splendour of the Grand Canyon and Ned says "Golly. A gully." That's the sort of light comedy I hear coming from Hope's mouth. This has a lot of that, and some good action scenes, and those opening fight scenes that really do draw you in. (7/10)


0 of 0 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 11 user reviews »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
Edit

Details

Country:

USA

Language:

None | English

Release Date:

30 December 1917 (USA) See more »

Also Known As:

A gáncsnélküli lovag See more »

Company Credits

Show more on IMDbPro »

Technical Specs

Runtime:

(2006 alternate)

Sound Mix:

Silent

Color:

Black and White (tinted)

Aspect Ratio:

1.33 : 1
See full technical specs »

Contribute to This Page



Recently Viewed