Fanchon, the Cricket (1915) User Reviews

Pickford, the Waif

[boblipton · 6/10 · 12 November 2018]

This was considered a lost movie when Mary Pickford died. A copy turned up in the Cinematheque Francaise, as they so often do, and in cooperation with the Mary Pickford Foundation, the BFI, Flicker Alley.... oh, the usual suspects, it has been preserved, restored somewhat and made available on a Blu-Ray/dvd set. I looked at the dvd version. It's a handsome offering, with only a few imperfection on the print, and a handsome toning to the affair: golden for daylight, blue for night, red for interiors.

It's based on a novel and written for the screen by director James Kirkwood and Frances Marion. Mary is Fanchon, a poor girl of a French village. Her grandmother is supposed to be a witch, but Mary is a free spirit, running around in rags. She takes a shine to Jack Standing, but all of the young villagers despise her; she beats up real-life brother Jack Pickford, sticks her tongue out at real-life sister Lottie, saves Standing from drowning and finds his idiot brother and has a grand time romping around the wild in the Delaware Water Gap for the first half of the movie. Then, as so often happens, the plot eventuates.

It's the second Pickford vehicle that Frances Marion had a hand in writing (I don't count THE NEW YORK HAT), and Pickford gets a lot out of the 'waif' role. The two women would have a fruitful collaboration, and Marion would direct a movie or two for America's sweetheart. Still, things slow down in the second half, and Standing is pretty much a stiff all the way through. Costume design is partially to blame. With his knee pants, wide-brimmed hat and collar, he winds up looking like Grady Sutton; he performs his role with the lack of brio that Sutton put into his comic nullities.... but Standing is simply a nullity.

Still, it's always good when a long-lost feature of Miss Pickford shows up. I'm glad I saw it.

Not perfect but still beautiful

[Philipp_Flersheim · 7/10 · 19 February 2022]

Mary Pickford plays Fanchon, the granddaughter of a woman considered a witch by the villagers, who grows up wild in the woods somewhere in pre-revolutionary France. The film is about how Fanchon falls in love with Landry, the son of the wealthiest villager (Jack Standing) and eventually wins him despite his initial betrothal to village beauty Madelon (Mary's sister Lottie). In many ways this is a delightful film. It is beautifully photographed; the scenes in the woodland are outstanding. In this respect, 'Fanchon the Cricket' has the feel of an early and extraordinarily well-made nature film. It is quite different from well-photographed films of the German expressionist kind that began to develop in the years before the First World War, but it is no less artistic. Besides, 'Fanchon' has been preserved in pristine condition (or expertly restored). The copy I watched looked as sharp and clear as if it had been filmed yesterday, and the tinting (amber for daylight, blue-grey for dusk etc.) enhances the mood of the film. Another plus is Pickford's acting. She is vivacious and has a huge range of expressions. On the downside is James Kirkwood's direction, which I found distinctly uninspired. The plot does drag occasionally, and it could also have been fleshed out quite a bit more. Over fairly large parts of the film the title cards are too rare to clarify what is going on. What I found really disturbing was the modern music, which apparently has been specially composed for the film. It fits in no way. It has the wrong instruments and does not match the plot. I turned it off after a while and watched 'Fanchon' without sound. In sum, this film isn't perfect, but it is still beautiful and good to watch. It made me want to read George Sand's novel on which it is based.

Pickford rarity is no classic

[pfors-647-501497 · 5/10 · 23 March 2014]

A rare screening of this obscure Mary Pickford title was one of the most anticipated events from the 2014 Cinefest in Syracuse, N.Y., but, as is so often the case, rarity doesn't equate with quality. The film, lamely directed by James Kirkwood, lacks technique. Kirkwood keeps the actors grouped in tight bunches, more like a faithful sheepdog than a movie director, reflecting none of the dynamic energy of films from the same period produced under the auspices of D.W. Griffith, Cecil B. DeMille and Thomas Ince. The lovely and entrancing Pickford is always worth watching, but her role here doesn't provide enough dramatic weight, and nothing she does lingers in the memory except for a lively scrap with her real-life brother, Jack Pickford, who plays a bratty villager. Mary's rather homely sister, Lottie, also has a role, making this picture perhaps the only extant example of all three Pickford siblings appearing in the same film.

Pickford great but a few other issues

[SnoopyStyle · 6/10 · 24 July 2023]

Fanchon (Mary Pickford) is a wild girl living in the woods with her grandmother Fadet. The villagers suspect Fadet of being a witch. Fanchon is carefree and likes to prank the locals. She doesn't mind getting into fights with the boys. She falls in love with a villager but his father disapproves. There is family history.

This is a presumed lost film until it was recently discovered and recovered. It has silent star Mary Pickford and her siblings. There are unconfirmed rumors of other future stars. Pickford is great. On the other hand, I really don't like these older actors trying to play lovesick teenagers. On top of that, I don't like the folk rock music that is playing with the film. It sounds way too modern and clashes with the film. Nevertheless, this is fascinating and a definite must for any Pickford fans.

" Fanchon Survives "

[PamelaShort · 8/10 · 16 April 2014]

It may be considered a slender story and not well directed by James Kirkwood, but for Mary Pickford enthusiasts, Fanchon, the Cricket is a must see film. Exquistely photographed by Ed Wynard and filmed on location in the beautiful Delaware Water Gap. James Kirkwood wrote the scenario adapted from George Sand's novel, with the help of Mary's new friend, screen-writer Frances Marion. Set in the eighteenth century, Mary plays a wild girl who lives in the forest with her eccentric grandmother, whom the villagers consider a witch. As always Mary Pickford is extremely fetching to watch as she delightfully captivates the role with her usual spunk. This film is also notable as the first and only full-length film that features all three Pickfords, Mary, her brother Jack and sister Lottie. One exciting scene has Fanchon ( Mary Pickford ) having a very sprightly and boisterous tussle with the village scamp played by brother Jack Pickford. The Moving Picture World declared, "The picture runs so naturally, with the convincing simplicity of a fairy tale" and "There never was a Fanchon like Mary Pickford, none have ever surpassed and few have ever approached her work." Many of todays so-called sophisticated film audiences cannot appreciate the art of the whole silent film genre, therefore a full synopsis cannot capture nor do justice as watching this important historical experience is for real silent cinema enthusiasts. If the fortunate opportunity comes your way to view this fascinating Pickford film, I highly suggest don't miss it.

Soundtrack is distracting - snare drums

[pbmbox-imdb · 3/10 · 14 December 2020]

Unfortunately, the added soundtrack is distracting and not well done. For the first 45 minutes the "music" consists mostly of an acoustic guitar and a snare drum, and the "music" has no relation to the action on the screen, sounding more modern than anything that would have been played in a 1915 viewing. I finally turned the sound off for a while. Other instruments are added later in the film, but they still have little relation to the action and sound too modern.

Gorgeous film cinematographically, and Mary's an acting treat and BEAUTIFUL besides!

[mmipyle · 8/10 · 17 September 2020]

Due to the fact that I'd never watched "Fanchon the Cricket" (1915) with Mary Pickford, I remembered that I had bought the Blu-Ray/DVD set last year - so - I watched it last night. Based on the magnificent 19th century (1849) French novel La Petite Fadette, a superior read even now and very much still in print (new translation by Gretchen van Slyke available from Penn State University Press), written by Amartine-Lucile-Aurora Dupin who went under the nom de plume George Sand, the book was rather drastically changed by director James Kirkwood and scenarist Frances Marion into the film that remains. Considered when released "an adult fairy tale", that's the best way to accept it. Gorgeously photographed by cinematographer Edward Wynard, the recently released Flicker Alley combo Blu-Ray/DVD is still stunningly beautiful, with wonderfully toned and frequently tinted frames that draw the viewer into the scene with the players. The blue-toned shots of the rock cliffs in particular are geologically spellbinding and photographically stunning. Scenes filmed among leafy foliage somehow capture the rural essence of the mise-en-scene in an inviting way, and the people in these shots look like works of art. However, there's a lack of creativity in set-up shots and variety - in this case, I think the director's overseeing, not the cinematographer's fault necessarily - especially a huge lack of any sort of close-up shots - except for Mary. Director James Kirkwood is obviously not a director of much artistic creativity, though he tells the story - as written - in a nice perfunctory way that suits Mary Pickford's rambunctious waif characterization. We can figure from the beginning that she'll change the tide that's against her from the outset. It's strictly my opinion, but what struck me most about the minus parts of the movie is the editing: it's eccentric. Too much time spent on some scenes and not enough on others. But, one thing that struck me immediately about this film more than many other Mary Pickford films struck Kevin Brownlow the same way, for he wrote for the book Mary Pickford Rediscovered in 1999, "She is extraordinarily beautiful; the first close-up of her face among the glistening leaves comes as almost physical shock."

In the book the waif becomes rather wealthy through an inheritance after her grandmother's death. Here, the fairy tale telling has the poor girl remain always in the rural existence, and poor, until...well, I'll not give the full elements of the plot. As I said, it's an adult fairy tale.

When Mary died in 1979 she thought this film was lost, and, as it had always been a fine memory for her, that was obviously a disappointment. Now found - from two sources - this is a wonderful addition to the Pickford canon. Also in the cast besides Mary are her sister Lottie, her brother Jack, Jack Standing, Gertrude Norman, Russell Bassett, Dick Lee, Alexander Gaden, and others.

So disappointing!

[tiredmum · 2/10 · 24 July 2023]

I hate to leave such a review as I truly love silent films and was so excited to see this one as it was one I had never watched before but I had to turn it off after only 8 minutes of viewing. The music that has been chosen to accompany this classic is so awful and distracting that I couldn't stand it any longer than that. I could have muted my television but I feel the music is needed to help set the mood of and add interest to the scenes. I hope whomever is in charge of such things replaces the horrible 1960s B movie soundtrack with something more appropriate to the era and genre of this film.

Mary Pickford is wonderful

[gbill-74877 · 8/10 · 1 July 2021]

"I'll do anything you ask of me." "Then, kiss me!"

It's sad to learn that Pickford died thinking this film was lost, heartbroken because it was the only one in which she appeared with both her sister Lottie and brother Jack. It's heartwarming to see her playing the young waif, reaching across the years with her larger than life screen presence, and I could watch her cavort about and cause mischief for hours. What an amazing woman she was, to have the magnetism she did on the screen, and the business savvy off of it.

She has many wonderful moments in this film:

• Pretending to run away from leading man (Jack Standing) so that he can catch her.

• Dancing in the moonlight and watching her shadow, with the camera angled down on her marvelously.

• Facing away with outstretched arms at the water's edge, and then lying down on the rocky shore.

• Her expression and little squeezing of the eyelids when he kisses her hand near the end.

• Emerging from the waving field of grain to say hello and goodbye to the audience at the very end.

Such a list doesn't really do her playful energy and the feelings she conveyed justice, but suffice it to say she's impossibly cute and every bit as captivating today as she was then. It's a shame the story is kind of simple and not much is made of the fact that her old grandma is reputed to be a witch, but the film is well-paced and the scenes have a lot of life to them, thanks mostly to Pickford. The modern score from Julian Ducatenzeiler and Andy Gladbach is a little controversial but I thought it pretty nice, fitting the tone of the scenes and making me feel the link between the ages all the more; in 2021 watching a film from 1915 based on a novel from 1849. Then again, Pickford transcends time very well, all by herself.

I'll take the wild girl....

[schlagzeugplayer · 9/10 · 20 December 2023]

This is a really interesting film, to bad Mary Pickford never saw it, she thought itl was lost.

Seen other of her films but this one really shines for her. She is a beautiful lady. In so many scenes she radiates. The story is a adult fable of sorts. Wild girl gets the handsome gentry kind of thing. Not all is good though. Not going to spoil it but it gets interesting. So I watched the digital restoration it very well done. But I hate the added soundtrack. It reminds me of a sort of Grateful Dead fever dream. What should it of been ? More grandiose but in the spirit of the time period of the film. So really watch with the sound down or maybe your favorite stk. I even tried Cocteau Twins and it kind of worked.