Imagine being one of John Mayer’s most dedicated fans and being invited to an intimate concert, only for it to go off the rails thanks to an overbearing producer. That’s exactly what happens on the latest episode of the hidden camera reality show Impractical Jokers, which Consequence is previewing with the exclusive teaser clip below.

In the episode, James “Murr” Murray’s punishment is to antagonize Mayer’s fans while the singer-songwriter is giving an acoustic performance of his signature hit, “Your Body Is a Wonderland.” Besides cutting off Mayer mid-strum to tell him the backstage producers want “a little bit more” from his performance, Murr calls him “Johnny.”

To the further annoyance of fans, Murr is then instructed to move people out of the first row. A visibly fed-up Mayer finally says, “How about we don’t interrupt ever again!” Leaning further into the joke, Mayer kicks...