Andrews was a renowned national and international pageant title winner. Among the titles she won - 1989 Miss Just Us; 1990 South America Newcomer of the Year; 1996 Miss San Antonio USA; 1997 Miss Texas USofA; 1998 Miss South USofA; 1998 Miss Illinois Continental; 1999 Miss Gay USofA; 2001 Miss Texas Continental; 2004 Miss Florida Continental; 2004 Universal ShowQueen; 2004 Miss Continental; 2006 Miss International Queen; 2006 Miss Texas Entertainer of the Year; 2006 Miss National Entertainer of the Year.