Academy Awards, USA

2002	Winner Honorary Award	Actor, director, producer, creator of Sundance, inspiration to independent and innovative ... More Actor, director, producer, creator of Sundance, inspiration to independent and innovative filmmakers everywhere. (Oscar statuette)
1995	Nominee Oscar	Best Picture Quiz Show (1994) Shared with: Michael Jacobs Julian Krainin Michael Nozik
		Best Director Quiz Show (1994)
1981	Winner Oscar	Best Director Ordinary People (1980)
1974	Nominee Oscar	Best Actor in a Leading Role The Sting (1973)

Primetime Emmy Awards

2013	Nominee Primetime Emmy	Outstanding Documentary or Nonfiction Special All the President's Men Revisited (2013) Shared with: Andrew Lack (executive producer) Laura Michalchyshyn (executive producer) Nancy Daniels (executive producer) Denise Contis (executive producer) Peter Schnall (producer)
1963	Nominee Primetime Emmy	Outstanding Performance in a Supporting Role by an Actor Alcoa Premiere (1961) For episode "The Voice of Charlie Pont".

BAFTA Awards

1995	Nominee BAFTA Film Award	Best Film Quiz Show (1994) Shared with: Michael Jacobs Julian Krainin Michael Nozik
1971	Winner BAFTA Film Award	Best Actor Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) Tell Them Willie Boy Is Here (1969) Downhill Racer (1969)

20/20 Awards

2015

Nominee Felix

Best Director Quiz Show (1994)

AARP Movies for Grownups Awards

2019	Nominee Movies for Grownups Award	Best Actor The Old Man & the Gun (2018)
2014	Nominee Movies for Grownups Award	Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)
2011	Winner Career Achievement Award
2005	Nominee Movies for Grownups Award	Best Grownup Love Story The Clearing (2004) Shared with: Helen Mirren

Alliance of Women Film Journalists

2013

Nominee EDA Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Awards Circuit Community Awards

1994	Winner Honorable Mentions (The Next Ten Best Picture Contenders)	Honorable Mentions Quiz Show (1994)
	Nominee ACCA	Best Director Quiz Show (1994)

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards

1999

Nominee Blockbuster Entertainment Award

Favorite Actor - Drama/Romance The Horse Whisperer (1998)

Boston Society of Film Critics Awards

1994

Nominee BSFC Award

Best Director Quiz Show (1994)

Chicago Film Critics Association Awards

2013

Nominee CFCA Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Chicago International Film Festival

2014

Nominee Audience Choice Award

Audience Choice Award Cathedrals of Culture (2014) Shared with: Karim Aïnouz Michael Glawogger Michael Madsen Margreth Olin Wim Wenders

CINE Competition

2014	Winner CINE Masters' Series Award	Broadcast Division All the President's Men Revisited (2013) Shared with: Andrew Lack (executive producer) Laura Michalchyshyn (executive producer) Nancy Daniels (executive producer) Denise Contis (executive producer) Peter Schnall (producer director)
	Winner CINE Golden Eagle	Documentary All the President's Men Revisited (2013) Shared with: Andrew Lack (executive producer) Laura Michalchyshyn (executive producer) Nancy Daniels (executive producer) Denise Contis (executive producer) Peter Schnall (producer director)

Critics Choice Awards

2014

Nominee Critics Choice Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

César Awards, France

2019

Winner Honorary César

Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Awards

1995

Nominee DFWFCA Award

Best Director Quiz Show (1994)

David di Donatello Awards

1986	Nominee David	Best Foreign Actor (Migliore Attore Straniero) Out of Africa (1985)
1974	Winner David	Best Foreign Actor (Migliore Attore Straniero) The Sting (1973) Tied with Al Pacino for Serpico (1973).

Detroit Film Critics Society Awards

2013

Nominee DFCS Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Directors Guild of America, USA

1995	Nominee DGA Award	Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Motion Pictures Quiz Show (1994)
1981	Winner DGA Award	Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Motion Pictures Ordinary People (1980) Shared with: Ronald L. Schwary (unit production manager) (plaque) Steve Perry (first assistant director) (plaque) Michael Britton (second assistant director) (plaque)

Film Independent Spirit Awards

2014

Nominee Independent Spirit Award

Best Male Lead All Is Lost (2013)

Film Society of Lincoln Center

2015

Winner Gala Tribute

Genesis Awards

2017

Winner Genesis Award

Outstanding TV Documentary Series Ocean Warriors (2016) Shared with: Paul Allen Mark Benjamin Marc Levin Laura Michalchyshyn Pagan Danielle Harleman David Casey Carole Tomko Jody Gottlieb Rocky Collins Elizabeth Bronstein Jerry Decker Kara Rozansky Patrick Keegan Katie Carpenter Yoav Attias Christopher Bryson Peter Schmuhl Adam Schleifer Nicholas Burnett

Global Nonviolent Film Festival

2012

Winner Jury Prize

Best Director The Conspirator (2010)

Golden Apple Awards

1973

Winner Golden Apple

Male Star of the Year

Golden Globes, USA

2019	Nominee Golden Globe	Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Musical or Comedy The Old Man & the Gun (2018)
2014	Nominee Golden Globe	Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Drama All Is Lost (2013)
1999	Nominee Golden Globe	Best Director - Motion Picture The Horse Whisperer (1998)
1995	Nominee Golden Globe	Best Director - Motion Picture Quiz Show (1994)
1994	Winner Cecil B. DeMille Award
1993	Nominee Golden Globe	Best Director - Motion Picture A River Runs Through It (1992)
1981	Winner Golden Globe	Best Director - Motion Picture Ordinary People (1980)
1978	Winner Henrietta Award	World Film Favorite - Male
1977	Winner Henrietta Award	World Film Favorite - Male
1975	Winner Henrietta Award	World Film Favorite - Male
1966	Winner Golden Globe	Most Promising Newcomer - Male Inside Daisy Clover (1965)

Gotham Awards

2015	Winner Tribute Award
2013	Nominee Gotham Independent Film Award	Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Hasty Pudding Theatricals, USA

1970

Winner Man of the Year

Houston Film Critics Society Awards

2013

Nominee HFCS Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

IGN Summer Movie Awards

2013

Nominee IGN Award

Best Movie Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Indiewire Critics' Poll

2013

Nominee ICP Award

Best Lead Performance All Is Lost (2013) 7th place.

International Documentary Association

2014	Winner Career Achievement Award
	Nominee IDA Award	Best Limited Series Chicagoland (2014) Shared with: Mark Benjamin (executive producer) Marc Levin (executive producer) Laura Michalchyshyn (executive producer)
2013	Nominee Video Source Award	All the President's Men Revisited (2013) Shared with: Peter Schnall (director/producer) Andrew Lack (executive producer) Laura Michalchyshyn (executive producer) Chana Gazit (writer) Patrick Prentice (writer)

Italian National Syndicate of Film Journalists

1981

Nominee Silver Ribbon

Best Foreign Director (Regista del Miglior Film Straniero) Ordinary People (1980)

Jupiter Award

1980

Nominee Jupiter Award

Best International Actor Brubaker (1980)

Kansas City Film Critics Circle Awards

1980

Winner KCFCC Award

Best Director Ordinary People (1980)

Karlovy Vary International Film Festival

2005

Winner Special Prize for Outstanding Contribution to World Cinema

Kinema Junpo Awards

1994

Winner Readers' Choice Award

Best Foreign Language Film A River Runs Through It (1992)

Laurel Awards

1971	Nominee Golden Laurel	Best Action Performance Little Fauss and Big Halsy (1970)
1970	Nominee Golden Laurel	Action Performance Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) 5th place.
1968	Nominee Golden Laurel	Male Comedy Performance Barefoot in the Park (1967) 5th place.
1966	Nominee Golden Laurel	New Faces, Male 10th place.

Maverick Movie Awards

2012

Nominee Maverick Movie Award

Best Performance: Short The Movement: One Man Joins an Uprising (2011) Shared with: Warren Miller

Nashville Film Festival

2001

Winner Freedom in Film Award

National Board of Review, USA

1980

Winner NBR Award

Best Director Ordinary People (1980)

National Society of Film Critics Awards, USA

2014	Nominee NSFC Award	Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)
1970	Nominee NSFC Award	Best Actor Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) Downhill Racer (1969) Tied with Michel Bouquet for La femme infidèle (1969) in 3rd place.

New York Film Critics Circle Awards

2013	Winner NYFCC Award	Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)
1980	Nominee NYFCC Award	Best Director Ordinary People (1980)
1969	Nominee NYFCC Award	Best Actor Downhill Racer (1969)

North Carolina Film Critics Association

2014

Nominee NCFCA Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Online Film & Television Association

2018	Winner OFTA Film Hall of Fame	Acting
		Creative

Online Film Critics Society Awards

2019

Winner Lifetime Achievement Award

Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards

2013

Nominee PFCS Award

Best Actor in a Leading Role All Is Lost (2013)

Razzie Awards

1994

Nominee Razzie Award

Worst Actor Indecent Proposal (1993)

Russian National Movie Awards

2014

Winner Georges Award

Empire Special Prize Empire Icon

San Francisco Film Critics Circle

2013

Nominee SFFCC Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

San Francisco International Film Festival

2009

Winner Peter J. Owens Award

Santa Barbara International Film Festival

2014

Winner American Riviera Award

Satellite Awards

2019	Nominee Satellite Award	Best Actor in a Motion Picture, Drama The Old Man & the Gun (2018)
2014	Nominee Satellite Award	Best Actor in a Motion Picture All Is Lost (2013)

Screen Actors Guild Awards

1996

Winner Life Achievement Award

Shanghai International Film Festival

2001

Nominee Golden Goblet

Best Film The Legend of Bagger Vance (2000)

ShoWest Convention, USA

2008

Winner Visionary Award

Sports Emmy Awards

2019

Nominee Emmy

Outstanding Long Sports Documentary Momentum Generation (2018) Shared with: Karen Lauder (executive producer) Greg Little (executive producer) Laura Michalchyshyn (executive producer) Jeff Zimbalist (director) Michael Zimbalist (director)

Telluride Film Festival, US

2013

Winner Silver Medallion Award

The Kennedy Center Honors

2005

Winner Kennedy Center Honors

The Stinkers Bad Movie Awards

1993

Nominee Stinker Award

Worst Actor Indecent Proposal (1993)

Venice Film Festival

2017	Winner Career Golden Lion
2012	Winner Vittorio Veneto Film Festival Award	The Company You Keep (2012)
	Winner Open Prize	The Company You Keep (2012)

Village Voice Film Poll

2013

Nominee VVFP Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013) 4th place.

Washington DC Area Film Critics Association Awards

2013

Nominee WAFCA Award

Best Actor All Is Lost (2013)

Western Heritage Awards

1972

Winner Bronze Wrangler

Theatrical Motion Picture Jeremiah Johnson (1972) Shared with: Joe Wizan (producer) Sydney Pollack (director) John Milius (writer) Edward Anhalt (writer) Will Geer (actor) Delle Bolton (actor)