Reviews written by registered user
|1 reviews in total|
For a long time I've wondered if radical groups like the ELF are
crucial to the causes they support because their tactics bring
much-needed attention to the causes, or if they are detrimental because
their tactics turn off many people who'd normally be sympathetic to
their causes. This film reinforces for me that the answer is "yes" and
"yes" -- i.e., "it depends" ... on the cause, on the specific tactics,
and ultimately on personal points of view.
IF A TREE FALLS added an interesting angle for me in this notion of the positive/negative net effect of radicalism. I had never thought about the impact of law enforcement's treatment of the radical groups -- i.e., do their tactics (brutal in many cases toward environmental protesters) help or hinder THEIR cause? As I watched the film, I wondered if there were disagreements about tactics/approaches within law enforcement akin to the disagreements within the ELF and the broader environmental activist community.
And that's what makes this film so strong and effective. It prompts you to ask a lot of questions. IF A TREE FALLS does it in a way that is character driven. The broader story unfolds through the stories of individuals who were involved. The result is that you (the audience) get involved!
I highly recommend the film. And like me, you may want to revisit THE THIN BLUE LINE and FIGHT CLUB after you see IF A TREE FALLS.